In the UK, everyone eating a healthy diet makes economic sense, but in poorer nations it's not so simple

November 10, 2010

In the second paper in The Lancet Series on Chronic Disease and Development, experts show that in the UK everyone eating a healthy diet would deliver big health effects with minimal knock-on effects to domestic agriculture and trade. But in a middle-income country like Brazil, it's a different story. There, healthier eating (both in Brazil or the UK) could have a major impact on agriculture, trade, and, by definition, jobs. The second paper is by Professor Richard Smith, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, UK, and colleagues. The paper is the first to examine the health and economic knock-on effects of healthy eating together in this manner.

Transition to diets that are high in saturated fat and sugar has caused a global public health concern, as the pattern of food consumption is a major modifiable risk factor for chronic non-communicable diseases. For example, cardiovascular disease is the world's leading cause of death, and although the number of deaths from such disease is highest in high-income

countries, it is rapidly becoming a major health burden in middle-income countries. But unlike many risk factors for other diseases, changing dietary habits to target chronic disease can have a major impact on the wider economy of the country concerned, and other countries who produce and export diet-related products, thus causing disruption to vested interests, while also having variable impacts on health. Yet although agri-food systems are intimately associated with this transition towards western diets, agriculture and health sectors are largely disconnected in their priorities, policy, and analysis, with neither side considering the complex inter-relation between agri-trade, patterns of food consumption, health, and development.

Improvements to diets will necessitate changes in agricultural production and trade worldwide, resulting in various winners and losers between sectors of the economy, rural and urban communities, and regions and countries.

Adherence to WHO dietary recommendations in Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) countries would mean a substantial decrease in the consumption of vegetable oils (by 30%), dairy products (by 28%), animal fats (by 30%), meat (eg, pork by 13•5% or mutton and goat by 14•5%), and sugar (by 24%), and a substantial increase in the consumption of cereals (by 31%), fruits (by 25%), and vegetables (by 21%). The UK government has estimated that, if diets matched nutritional guidelines, 70 000 premature deaths could be prevented each year, with a saving to the health service of £20 billion every year.

The authors estimated that, to meet WHO healthy eating guidelines of no more than 10% of dietary energy as saturated fat, adults in the UK would need to reduce dietary saturated fat consumption by 22%, and adults in São Paulo by 7%. These figures equate to reductions of 7% in disability-adjusted life years and 3270 (3%) premature deaths averted in 1 year in the UK, and reductions of 3% of disability-adjusted life years and 2800 (2%) premature deaths averted in 1 year in Brazil.

But reductions similar to those required above by the UK, if translated across the EU, could have a massive impact on major meat exporters such as Brazil and China, damaging their economies and causing widespread job losses. The world economy would have to adjust to less meat and dairy produce. However, the authors point out that the jobs lost in the meat industry could be at least partly replaced by jobs elsewhere in agriculture, as other sectors such as cereal and fruit production increase to make up the calories lost from the diet through meat.

The authors say: "The benefits of such a healthy diet policy will vary between populations, not only because of population dietary intake but also because of agricultural production, trade, and economic factors... Knowledge of the effects of dietary change on both national health and wealth, and of winners and losers from policy change, are essential to secure a sustainable food policy to maximise health benefits and minimise potential risks."

They add: "Our analysis suggests that the UK would acrue substantial health benefits and associated low costs from adoption of a diet low in saturated fat from animal sources. Conversely, Brazil would experience little health benefit but far more striking economic costs from such a policy."

They conclude: "Public health policy makers need to judge whether present agriculture and trade are contributing to--or detracting from-- efforts to attain dietary goals, and how agricultural policy interventions could help achieve dietary goals."
-end-
Professor Richard Smith, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, UK. T) +44 (0) 20 7927 2403 E) richard.smith@lshtm.ac.uk

For full Series paper 2, see: http://press.thelancet.com/cdd2.pdf

NOTE: THE ABOVE LINK IS FOR JOURNALISTS ONLY. IF YOU WISH YOU CAN PROVIDE A LINK TO THE DEDICATED SERIES PAGE ON THE LANCET.COM, WHERE ALL USERS CAN DOWNLOAD PAPERS FOR FREE ONCE THEY HAVE REGISTERED (ALSO FREE). LINK AS BELOW:
http://www.thelancet.com/series/chronic-diseases-and-development

Lancet

Related Chronic Disease Articles from Brightsurf:

How to ensure patients manage their chronic kidney disease
A Singapore study finds patients with chronic kidney disease need tailored nutrition guidance, as well as better communication with doctors and family support, to empower them to manage their condition.

COVID-19 a double blow for chronic disease patients
The COVID-19 pandemic has escalated into a 'syndemic' for people with chronic illnesses, a new UNSW study analysing data from low and middle-income countries shows.

Children with chronic kidney disease have outsized health burden
Chronically ill children with kidney disease may spend more time in the hospital, incur larger health care costs and have a higher risk of death compared to pediatric patients hospitalized for other chronic conditions, a new study suggests.

Your neighborhood may raise your risk of chronic kidney disease
A neighborhood's overall socioeconomic status, including income and education-level, may influence its residents' risk of chronic kidney disease, according to a study recently published in SSM Population Health by researchers from Drexel University's Dornsife School of Public Health.

Antioxidant agent may prevent chronic kidney disease and Parkinson's disease
Researchers from Osaka University developed a novel dietary silicon-based antioxidant agent with renoprotective and neuroprotective effects.

Chronic disease prevention could ease opioid crisis
Preventing chronic disease could help curb the opioid epidemic, according to research from the University of Georgia.

New study provides insight into chronic kidney disease
Researchers have further analyzed a known signaling pathway they believe brings them one step closer to understanding the complex physiology of patients with chronic kidney disease (CKD), which might provide a path to new treatment options.

Predicting risk of chronic kidney disease
Data from about 5 million people (with and without diabetes) in 28 countries were used to develop equations to help identify people at increased five-year risk of chronic kidney disease, defined as reduced estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR).

Milk and dairy products can help prevent chronic disease
Ángel Gil, Professor of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology at the University of Granada, has recently coordinated a study reviewing worldwide scientific literature on the role of dairy products in health and in the prevention of chronic diseases (cardiovascular, metabolic syndrome, colon or bladder cancer, and type 2 diabetes).

Digital health must be reimbursed to cope with chronic disease
Sophia Antipolis, 28 March 2019: Health systems must reimburse digital health and integrate it into routine care to cope with chronic disease.

Read More: Chronic Disease News and Chronic Disease Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.