Role Of Government Branches In Tobacco War

November 10, 1998

EDITORS: Peter Jacobson will present the article, "Litigation as Public Health Policymaking: The Case of Tobacco Control," 12:15-1:45 p.m. Nov. 18 at the Washington Hilton during at the American Public Health Association annual meeting.


ANN ARBOR---Public health advocates who support tobacco control litigation believe the legislative and regulatory arms of government have failed to control tobacco use, so they've turned to the court system in an effort to create policies designed to protect the public from tobacco harms. In some ways, those efforts have paid off because litigation has influenced public health policy, but litigation alone won't solve the problem and may not be the best way to change tobacco control policy, according to a new University of Michigan study.

"Litigation to form public policy is probably not going to achieve the policy goals tobacco control advocates would like to see, in part because of the limits on the types of policies courts can influence. The courts are not well suited for adopting policy changes. Public health advocates need to build a moral and political case as to why tobacco should be controlled," said Peter D. Jacobson, senior author of an article forthcoming in the June issue of the Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law.

Jacobson, U-M associate professor of health management and policy, and Kenneth E. Warner, U-M professor of health management and policy, examine the role of tobacco litigation in shaping public policy in the article, "Litigation and Public Health Policymaking: The Case of Tobacco Control."

Jacobson will present the results of the study on Nov. 18 at the annual meeting of the American Public Health Association in Washington, D.C.

The authors argue the traditional avenue of forming public policy, through legislative and regulatory processes, is likely to be more effective in achieving public health goals.

The authors raise these arguments:"Our conclusions are unlikely to satisfy either the proponents or opponents of litigation as policy. But, democracy is often an untidy and disorderly process where our three branches of government collide," Jacobson said.

The study was funded by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation's Investigator Awards in Health Policy Research Program.
-end-


University of Michigan

Related Tobacco Articles from Brightsurf:

UC studies tobacco use, cancer connection
Researchers at the University of Cincinnati have identified new clues into ways tobacco use impacts patients with kidney cancer.

'Best' hospitals should be required to deliver tobacco treatment
A UCLA-led report published today in the Journal of the American Medical Association Internal Medicine exposes what the authors call a weakness in the high-profile 'Best Hospitals Honor Roll' published annually by US News and World Report.

Small shops, heavy advertisers less likely to ID for tobacco
'Our findings suggest that certain types of stores -- tobacco shops, convenience stores and those with a lot of tobacco advertising -- are more likely to sell tobacco to a young person without checking his or her ID.'

Youth smoking and vaping: What does it mean for tobacco control
New research from PIRE/PRC features analysis of in-depth, qualitative interviews with young vapers in California between 15 and 25.

Truth telling about tobacco and nicotine
In 'Truth Telling about Tobacco and Nicotine,' PRC researchers explain that, although there is agreement among researchers about evidence that vaping can be less harmful than combustible cigarettes, the tobacco control community remains divided about how to communicate -- or even whether to communicate -- information about the relative risks of tobacco and nicotine products.

A 'joint' problem: Investigating marijuana and tobacco co-use
A survey of marijuana and tobacco co-users by Medical University of South Carolina investigators found that co-users with high degree of interrelatedness between their use of the two substances had greater tobacco dependence and smoked more cigarettes per day.

How genes affect tobacco and alcohol use
A new study gives insight into the complexity of genetic and environmental factors that compel some of us to drink and smoke more than others.

Tobacco use linked with higher use of opioids and sedatives
Tobacco is a known risk factor for the misuse of prescription opioids.

Changes in flavored tobacco product use among youth tobacco users
Self-reportedĀ use of flavored tobacco products by middle and high school students decreased from 2014 to 2016 but climbed back up in 2017 in an analysis of national survey data.

Heated tobacco product claims by tobacco industry scrutinized by UCSF researchers
Claims by the tobacco industry that heated tobacco products (HTPs) are safer than conventional cigarettes are not supported by the industry's own data and are likely to be misunderstood by consumers, according to research published in a special issue of Tobacco Control.

Read More: Tobacco News and Tobacco Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.