Study of Mexican swine flu cases shows young people most likely to be infected but elderly most likely to die from the disease

November 11, 2009

A study of Mexican swine flu cases shows that while infants and people aged 39 years and under are the most likely to get infected, elderly people have the highest swine flu mortality rates. The data, which covers the period up to July 31, 2009, is reported in an Article published Online First ( and in an upcoming edition of The Lancet. The Article is written by Dr Victor Borja-Aburto, Mexican Institute for Social Security, Mexico City, Mexico, and colleagues.

The authors analysed information gathered by the influenza surveillance system from April 28 to July 31, 2009, for patients with influenza-like illness who attended clinics that were part of the Mexican Institute for Social Security network. They found that, July 31, 63,479 cases of influenza like illness were reported; 6945 (11%) cases of H1N1 were confirmed. Of these, 6407 (92%) were outpatients, 475 (7%) were admitted and survived, and 63 (< 1%) died. Those aged 10-39 years were most affected (3922 [56%]). Mortality rates showed a J-shaped curve, with greatest risk in those aged 70 years and older (10•3%). The following mortality rates were recorded in other age groups: 60--69 years 5.7%; 50--59 years 4.5%; 40--49 years 2.7%; 30--39 years 2.0%; under 1 year 1.6%; 20--29 years 0.9%; 1--9 years 0.3%; 10--19 years 0.2%.

Risk of infection was lowered by 35% in those who had been vaccinated for seasonal influenza. Every day of delay in hospital admission after the fourth day of symptoms onset increased the risk of death by almost 20%, and presence of chronic diseases in a person increased their risk of death six-fold.

The authors point out that pregnant women accounted for 6% of the deaths in their study (four of 63), slightly lower than the rate recorded in the USA during a similar period (8%, seven of 87 deaths). The authors say: "In Mexico, all pregnant workers were sent home during the peak of the pandemic, which probably accounts for this difference. Information about pregnancy in ambulatory confirmed cases was not available in the surveillance system, and we were unable to estimate the case fatality rate for pregnant women. None of the pregnant patients who died received antiviral drugs during the first 48 h and none had received influenza vaccine. Treatment should begin immediately after onset of symptoms in this group, and vaccination during pregnancy is not contraindicated and therefore can be considered."

Possible protection against H1N1 flu through the seasonal influenza vaccine is, the authors acknowledge, controversial. They say: "The Mexican population who has received seasonal influenza vaccination since 1977, including H1N1 components, could have benefited from cross immunity. The high incidence of infection in young people could show not only their different exposure related to their daily activities but also that people older than 60 years might have some immunity against the H1N1 virus."

The authors conclude: "Although H1N1 has spread to 168 countries and territories worldwide, it has not reached the dimensions of its great predecessor in 1918, and some researchers believe, with the information available up to now, that the present H1N1 influenza virus will not cause a pandemic on the scale of those during the 20th century. This pandemic might not be the one we expected; however, the virus is evolving and the threat continues."

In an accompanying Comment, Dr V Alberto Laguna-Torres, San Marcos University, Lima-Peru, and, US Naval Medical Research Center Detachment, Lima, Peru and Dr Jorge Gomez Benavides, Ministry of Health of Peru, Lima, Peru, say: "A significant finding in today's report was the higher infection risk in children, but the disease was more severe (ie, higher risk of death) in people older than 60 years. Additionally, school closures and restrictions of mass gatherings to mitigate the spread of the epidemic was successful, as has been seen in other countries."

They conclude: "Decisions based on preliminary results and limited sources have to be made, and sometimes there is no time to wait for the pandemic to end to have stronger information. Currently we know that the pandemic has not reached the dimensions of its predecessor in 1918, but the scientific knowledge has evolved faster than before, probably because of global and online communication."
Dr Victor Borja-Aburto, Mexican Institute for Social Security, Mexico City, Mexico. T) +52 55 55361539 / +52 55 32328834 E)

Dr V Alberto Laguna-Torres, San Marcos University, Lima, Peru T) +51-1 614-4166 E) /

Dr Jorge Gomez Benavides, Ministry of Health of Peru, Lima, Peru. T) +51 1-330 1534 E)

For full Article and Comment, see:


Related Influenza Articles from Brightsurf:

Predicting influenza epidemics
Researchers at Linköping University, Sweden, have developed a unique method to predict influenza epidemics by combining several sources of data.

Common cold combats influenza
As the flu season approaches, a strained public health system may have a surprising ally -- the common cold virus.

Scent-sensing cells have a better way to fight influenza
Smell receptors that line the nose get hit by Influenza B just like other cells, but they are able to clear the infection without dying.

New antivirals for influenza and Zika
Leuven researchers have deployed synthetic amyloids to trigger protein misfolding as a strategy to combat the influenza A and Zika virus.

Assessment of deaths from COVID-19, seasonal influenza
Publicly available data were used to analyze the number of deaths from seasonal influenza deaths compared with deaths from COVID-19.

Obesity promotes virulence of influenza
Obesity promotes the virulence of the influenza virus, according to a study conducted in mice published in mBio, an open-access journal of the American Society for Microbiology.

Influenza: combating bacterial superinfection with the help of the microbiota
Frenc researchers and from Brazilian (Belo Horizonte), Scottish (Glasgow) and Danish (Copenhagen) laboratories have shown for the first time in mice that perturbation of the gut microbiota caused by the influenza virus favours secondary bacterial superinfection.

Chemists unveil the structure of an influenza B protein
MIT chemists have discovered the structure of an influenza B protein called BM2, a finding that could help researchers design drugs that block the protein and help prevent the virus from spreading.

How proteins help influenza A bind and slice its way to cells
Researchers have provided new insight on how two proteins help influenza A virus particles fight their way to human cells.

Eating elderberries can help minimize influenza symptoms
Conducted by Professor Fariba Deghani, Dr. Golnoosh Torabian and Dr.

Read More: Influenza News and Influenza Current Events is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to