Nav: Home

Modeling the promise and peril of gene drive

November 12, 2015

BETHESDA, MD - What if we could eradicate malaria by engineering a mosquito population that doesn't transmit the disease? What if we could control invasive species that outcompete natural populations? What if we could get rid of insecticide-resistant pests not by developing new chemical treatments, but instead by changing the population itself and driving it toward extinction?

Although scientists have long-imagined the potential of biological interventions to solve challenges like these, the ability of the CRISPR/Cas9 system to precisely edit genetic material, coupled with gene drive systems, offers a hope of success that's within reach. But this potential gain also carries potential risks.

Much of the increasing attention to gene drive, including recent news coverage, has raised questions about whether these constructs can have their desired effect without simultaneously causing ecological harm.

A new report from Unckless et al. recently published in the journal GENETICS builds on recent experimental work being carried out in the field by using mathematical models to estimate how quickly such gene replacement can spread through a population.

Modeling several scenarios using a Wright-Fisher model as their foundation, Unckless et al. demonstrate that adding modified genes through the mutagenic chain reaction (MCR) can have dramatic effects, with these genes fixing in populations after only a few generations, much more quickly that they would as a result of natural selection. Moreover, gene drive allows the potential of a particular allele to spread through a population, even if there is selection operating against it.

The efficiency of these methods allows effects of this biological control strategy to appear very quickly, which may prove extraordinarily effective. That very speed and efficiency, which on one hand would be beneficial, also brings some level of risk for unintended consequences that are difficult if not impossible to control.

"We need to consider the population dynamics of gene drive in designing these types of strategies," emphasizes study author Rob Unckless of Cornell University. "The outcome will vary considerably based on the strength of drive, fitness consequences, and dominance, and other factors. This means that we can't insert any old mutation into any site in the genome and expect that within tens of generations, the population will be fixed for that mutation." But this result may be possible in some instances.

"We need to try these techniques in very limited scales - first cages then enclosures - to assess how it spreads," said Unckless.

Unckless also suggests that modeling should be done with multiple constructs, including beneficial mutations, deleterious mutations, different conversion efficiencies, and rates of non-homologous end joining, among others. In their paper, Unckless and colleagues explain how the math meets the applied: this modeling of MCR population dynamics can both put bounds on the frequency trajectories expected from the release of an MCR, but it may also identify possible choke points for controlling and preventing the expansion of an escaped or mutated MCR allele in a natural population.

Although Unckless suggests there's more work to be done to assess the potential and peril of gene drives, early indications suggest the possibility of dramatic effect.
CITATION: Unckless, R.L., Messer, P.W., Connallon, T., & A.G. Clark. 2015. Modeling the Manipulation of Natural Populations by Mutagenic Chain Reaction.GENETICS, 201:425-431. doi:

FUNDING: This work was supported by National Institutes of Health (NIH) grant R01-GM064590 (to A.G. Clark), NIH grant F32-HD071703 (to R.L. Unckless), and an Australian Research Council discovery grant (to T. Connallon).

About the Genetics Society of America (GSA)

Founded in 1931, the Genetics Society of America (GSA) is the professional scientific society for genetics researchers and educators. The Society's more than 5,500 members worldwide work to deepen our understanding of the living world by advancing the field of genetics, from the molecular to the population level. GSA promotes research and fosters communication through a number of GSA-sponsored conferences including regular meetings that focus on particular model organisms. GSA publishes two peer-reviewed, peer-edited scholarly journals: GENETICS, which has published high quality original research across the breadth of the field since 1916, and G3: Genes|Genomes|Genetics, an open-access journal launched in 2011 to disseminate high quality foundational research in genetics and genomics. The Society also has a deep commitment to education and fostering the next generation of scholars in the field. For more information about GSA, please visit

Genetics Society of America

Related Mathematical Models Articles:

Mathematical biology tackles destructive plant virus
Plant diseases pose a serious threat to global food security, especially in developing countries, where millions of people depend on consuming what they harvest.
Mystery of how sperm swim revealed in mathematical formula
Researchers have developed a mathematical formula based on the rhythmic movement of a sperm's head and tail, which significantly reduces the complexities of understanding and predicting how sperm make the difficult journey towards fertilizing an egg.
Mathematical model limits malaria outbreaks
Mathematical models can effectively predict and track malaria transmission trends, ultimately quantifying the efficiency of various treatment and eradication strategies in high-risk regions.
Mathematical algorithms calculate social behavior
For a long time, mathematical modelling of social systems and dynamics was considered in the realm of science fiction.
Researchers found mathematical structure that was thought not to exist
Researchers found mathematical structure that was thought not to exist.
Unavoidable tools for handling mathematical models: Bessel and Mittag-Leffler functions
This book analyzes applied analysis through the study of enumerable families of different classes of special functions.
Fluoride consumption linked to diabetes using mathematical models
A recent study published in the Journal of Water and Health examined links between water fluoridation and diabetes.
Mathematical models explain east-west asymmetry of jet lag recovery
Travelers frequently report experiencing a significantly slower jet lag recovery after an eastward vs. westward flight.
Researchers create first 3-D mathematical model of uterine contractions
By studying the electric activity that causes uterine contractions in pregnant women, researchers at Washington University in St.
Exploring the mathematical universe
A team of more than 80 mathematicians from 12 countries has begun charting the terrain of rich, new mathematical worlds, and sharing their discoveries on the Web.

Related Mathematical Models Reading:

Best Science Podcasts 2019

We have hand picked the best science podcasts for 2019. Sit back and enjoy new science podcasts updated daily from your favorite science news services and scientists.
Now Playing: TED Radio Hour

Jumpstarting Creativity
Our greatest breakthroughs and triumphs have one thing in common: creativity. But how do you ignite it? And how do you rekindle it? This hour, TED speakers explore ideas on jumpstarting creativity. Guests include economist Tim Harford, producer Helen Marriage, artificial intelligence researcher Steve Engels, and behavioral scientist Marily Oppezzo.
Now Playing: Science for the People

#524 The Human Network
What does a network of humans look like and how does it work? How does information spread? How do decisions and opinions spread? What gets distorted as it moves through the network and why? This week we dig into the ins and outs of human networks with Matthew Jackson, Professor of Economics at Stanford University and author of the book "The Human Network: How Your Social Position Determines Your Power, Beliefs, and Behaviours".