New standard proposed for supercomputing

November 15, 2010

ALBUQUERQUE, N.M. -- A new supercomputer rating system will be released by an international team led by Sandia National Laboratories at the Supercomputing Conference 2010 in New Orleans on Nov. 17.

The rating system, Graph500, tests supercomputers for their skill in analyzing large, graph-based structures that link the huge numbers of data points present in biological, social and security problems, among other areas.

"By creating this test, we hope to influence computer makers to build computers with the architecture to deal with these increasingly complex problems," Sandia researcher Richard Murphy said.

Rob Leland, director of Sandia's Computations, Computers, and Math Center, said, "The thoughtful definition of this new competitive standard is both subtle and important, as it may heavily influence computer architecture for decades to come."

The group isn't trying to compete with Linpack, the current standard test of supercomputer speed, Murphy said. "There have been lots of attempts to supplant it, and our philosophy is simply that it doesn't measure performance for the applications we need, so we need another, hopefully complementary, test," he said.

Many scientists view Linpack as a "plain vanilla" test mechanism that tells how fast a computer can perform basic calculations, but has little relationship to the actual problems the machines must solve.

The impetus to achieve a supplemental test code came about at "an exciting dinner conversation at Supercomputing 2009," said Murphy. "A core group of us recruited other professional colleagues, and the effort grew into an international steering committee of over 30 people." (See www.graph500.org.)

Many large computer makers have indicated interest, said Murphy, adding there's been buy-in from Intel, IBM, AMD, NVIDIA, and Oracle corporations. "Whether or not they submit test results remains to be seen, but their representatives are on our steering committee."

Each organization has donated time and expertise of committee members, he said.

While some computer makers and their architects may prefer to ignore a new test for fear their machine will not do well, the hope is that large-scale demand for a more complex test will be a natural outgrowth of the greater complexity of problems.

Studies show that moving data around (not simple computations) will be the dominant energy problem on exascale machines, the next frontier in supercomputing, and the subject of a nascent U.S. Department of Energy initiative to achieve this next level of operations within a decade, Leland said. (Petascale and exascale represent 10 to the 15th and 18th powers, respectively, operations per second.)

Part of the goal of the Graph500 list is to point out that in addition to more expense in data movement, any shift in application base from physics to large-scale data problems is likely to further increase the application requirements for data movement, because memory and computational capability increase proportionally. That is, an exascale computer requires an exascale memory.

"In short, we're going to have to rethink how we build computers to solve these problems, and the Graph500 is meant as an early stake in the ground for these application requirements," said Murphy.

How does it work?

Large data problems are very different from ordinary physics problems.

Unlike a typical computation-oriented application, large-data analysis often involves searching large, sparse data sets performing very simple computational operations.

To deal with this, the Graph 500 benchmark creates two computational kernels: a large graph that inscribes and links huge numbers of participants and a parallel search of that graph.

"We want to look at the results of ensembles of simulations, or the outputs of big simulations in an automated fashion," Murphy said. "The Graph500 is a methodology for doing just that. You can think of them being complementary in that way -- graph problems can be used to figure out what the simulation actually told us."

Performance for these applications is dominated by the ability of the machine to sustain a large number of small, nearly random remote data accesses across its memory system and interconnects, as well as the parallelism available in the machine.

Five problems for these computational kernels could be cybersecurity, medical informatics, data enrichment, social networks and symbolic networks:"Many of us on the steering committee believe that these kinds of problems have the potential to eclipse traditional physics-based HPC [high performance computing] over the next decade," Murphy said.

While general agreement exists that complex simulations work well for the physical sciences, where lab work and simulations play off each other, there is some doubt they can solve social problems that have essentially infinite numbers of components. These include terrorism, war, epidemics and societal problems.

"These are exactly the areas that concern me," Murphy said. "There's been good graph-based analysis of pandemic flu. Facebook shows tremendous social science implications. Economic modeling this way shows promise.

"We're all engineers and we don't want to over-hype or over-promise, but there's real excitement about these kinds of big data problems right now," he said. "We see them as an integral part of science, and the community as a whole is slowly embracing that concept.

"However, it's so new we don't want to sound as if we're hyping the cure to all scientific ills. We're asking, 'What could a computer provide us?' and we know we're ignoring the human factors in problems that may stump the fastest computer. That'll have to be worked out."
-end-
Ssee Sandia website for image: This small, synthetic graph was generated by a method called Kronecker multiplication. Larger versions of this generator, modeling real-world graphs, are used in the Graph500 benchmark. (Courtesy of Jeremiah Willcock, Indiana University) Click on the thumbnail for a high-resolution image. A higher resolution EPS file of the image also is available upon request.

Sandia National Laboratories is a multiprogram laboratory operated and managed by Sandia Corporation, a wholly owned subsidiary of Lockheed Martin Corporation, for the U.S. Department of Energy's National Nuclear Security Administration. With main facilities in Albuquerque, N.M., and Livermore, Calif., Sandia has major R&D responsibilities in national security, energy and environmental technologies, and economic competitiveness.

DOE/Sandia National Laboratories

Related Supercomputing Articles from Brightsurf:

Keep the data coming
A continuous data supply ensures data-intensive simulations can run at maximum speed.

Supercomputing drug screening for deadly heart arrhythmias
First atomistic to tissue multiscale computational pipeline developed for screening drugs for cardiotoxicity.

Novel software to balance data processing load in supercomputers to be presented
The team will present its research in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, at the 33rd International Parallel and Distributed Processing Symposium on May 22, 2019.

VUMC researchers, supercomputing effort reveal antibody secrets
Using sophisticated gene sequencing and computing techniques, researchers at Vanderbilt University Medical Center (VUMC) and the San Diego Supercomputer Center have achieved a first-of-its-kind glimpse into how the body's immune system gears up to fight off infection.

Supercomputing propels jet atomization research for industrial processes
Researchers at the Bundeswehr University Munich recently appeared on the cover of the Journal of Fluid Mechanics for their simulations studying turbulence in jet sprays at the atomic level.

Supercomputing helps study two-dimensional materials
Computational scientists support experimentalist's quest to observe lithium atoms' behaviour when placed between two sheets of graphene.

Earthquake researchers finalists for supercomputing prize
A team of researchers from the University of Tokyo and RIKEN in Japan were finalists for the coveted Gordon Bell Prize for outstanding achievements in high-performance computing, praised for their simulation of earthquake physics in complex urban environments.

With supercomputing power, scientists solve a next-generation physics problem
Using the Titan supercomputer at the Oak Ridge Leadership Computing Facility, a team of researchers has calculated a fundamental property of protons and neutrons, known as the nucleon axial coupling, with groundbreaking precision.

Supercomputing the emergence of material behavior
Chemists at the University of California, San Diego designed the first artificial protein assembly (C98RhuA) whose conformational dynamics can be chemically and mechanically toggled.

Supercomputing speeds up deep learning training
Researchers from UC Berkeley, UC Davis and TACC used Stampede2 to complete a 100-epoch ImageNet deep neural network training in 11 minutes -- the fastest time recorded to date.

Read More: Supercomputing News and Supercomputing Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.