Twelve-point plan tackles moral and ethical issues of using email for health research

November 16, 2005

Email provides exciting new opportunities for health researchers but also raises a wide range of moral and ethical issues, according to a paper in the latest Journal of Advanced Nursing.

Patient confidentiality is paramount and making IT experts an integral part of any email-based research team is essential, says Dr Debbie Kralik from the University of South Australia.

"Researchers work to very strict ethical protocols" she says. "However, a variety of complex issues arise during email research that can make the application of traditional ethical standards, such as consent, identity and confidentiality, difficult."

Dr Kralik and her team from the School of Nursing and Midwifery have been using email as part of their joint research with the Royal District Nursing Service into how people live with chronic illness

Together with their technical expert - Dr Jim Warren from the University's Advanced Computer Research Centre - they have developed a 12-point plan which they feel may help other researchers considering email research.

"Using email has enabled us to carry out research with people over an extended period and at a time and pace that suits them, irrespective of geography. Because the people we are working with have chronic illnesses, it also enables us to include people who may not otherwise feel able to participate" adds Dr Kralik.

"But we need to approach this type of research carefully and ensure that as many safeguards as possible are put in place to protect participants."

A number of issues need to be considered before email research is undertaken. These include
"Although email can pose confidentiality risks, most people now see those risks as part of everyday life and recognise that it is up to them to use it morally and responsibly" says Dr Kralik.

"We believe that as researchers we are duty bound to stress the importance of confidentiality to all participants, while acknowledging that it cannot be guaranteed.

"Making an IT expert part of the research team is invaluable as it enables us to maximise the technical knowledge required to ensure that our end of the process is as secure as possible."

The Kralik team's 12-point plan provides valuable guidance for other researchers, based on their practical experience. It asks:

1. How will informed consent be obtained?
2. What will be known about a person's identity before they become a participant?
3. How can you be sure that you are researching with the people you think you are communicating with?
4. Will pseudonyms and online persona qualify as confidential information?
5. How will participants be informed about issues regarding the confidentiality of any records kept by the researcher or by participants?
6. Will participants be provided with the opportunity to debrief once the study is completed?
7. What will be discussed in the research report?
8. Will participants be able to provide feedback about the written research report?
9. How easily can other people access the group communications?
10. Is it possible for outsiders to find messages from participants? How will the identity of group members be kept confidential in the records and reports of the research?
11. Is there a possibility of harm to the person, the group or the group members by the research?
12. Have colleagues who are knowledgeable about the unique features of cyberspace been consulted about the ethical aspects of the study?

"Researchers using email are still on learning curve but we hope that our experience will add to the debate about the moral and ethical issues that need to be considered" says Dr Kralik.
Further information and press copies of the paper are available from:

Annette Whibley, Wizard Communications

Notes to editors

Blackwell Publishing Ltd.

Related Nursing Articles from Brightsurf:

Dismantling structural racism in nursing
Confronting the uncomfortable reality of systemic racism - the system that creates and maintains racial inequality in every facet of life for people of color - is having a national heyday.

MU School of Nursing programs help nursing homes respond to COVID-19
As the coronavirus pandemic continues to put a strain on health care systems, nursing homes have become overburdened with the challenge of keeping both patients and staff safe and healthy.

Palliative nursing's role during COVID-19 and beyond
As a rapid influx of patients overwhelmed health systems during the coronavirus pandemic, palliative nurses played dual roles supporting patients, patient families, and colleagues.

Calling for nursing support amid COVID-19 pandemic
There are close to 28 million nurses around the world who comprise a global workforce that delivers about 90 percent of primary healthcare, including frontline response to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Nursing research informs response to COVID-19 pandemic
Nursing research has an important influence on evidence-based health care practice, care delivery, and policy.

Designing better nursing care with robots
Robots are becoming an increasingly important part of human care, according to researchers based in Japan.

A work patch for better nursing home care
A research team, including a Purdue University work-life balance expert, studied work schedules in nursing home facilities and found a patching approach could benefit patients and staff.

Nursing science could help reduce firearm violence and its impact
Firearm violence is a significant public health problem worldwide. In the United States, firearms are used to kill almost 100 people daily.

A nursing perspective on the opioid crisis
Addictions nursing specialists have a unique role to play in caring for patients, families, and communities affected by the crisis.

Nursing notes can help indicate whether ICU patients will survive
Researchers at the University of Waterloo have found that sentiments in the nursing notes of health care providers are good indicators of whether intensive care unit (ICU) patients will survive.

Read More: Nursing News and Nursing Current Events is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to