Politically extreme counties may act as magnets, migration patterns suggest

November 26, 2019

UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. -- It may not be just location, location, location that influences where people move to in the United States, but also politics, politics, politics, according to a team of researchers.

In a study of county-to-county migration patterns in the U.S., the researchers found that when people migrate, they tend to move to other counties that reflect their political preferences. They added that the pattern also suggests that people moving from moderate partisan counties are just as likely to move to extreme partisan counties as they are to move to other moderate counties. However, people who live in a politically extreme county are significantly likely to move to a similarly extreme county.

This type of political sorting might turn extreme counties into "magnets" that pull people from moderate counties and exchange them with other extreme counties.

"We found that the places that were most likely to exhibit same-party preference in movement are counties that are politically extreme," said Bruce Desmarais, the DeGrandis-McCourtney Early Career Professor in Political Science, and a faculty co-hire of the Institute for Computational and Data Sciences (ICDS), Penn State. "What we saw was that movement from very Democratic or very Republican counties tended to be isolated to migration to other counties that are politically similar."

These migration patterns could be a mechanism behind the growing political divide in the country, added Desmarais, who worked with Xi Liu, former doctoral student in geography at Penn State, and currently a software engineer with Google; and Clio Andris, assistant professor of city and regional planning and interactive computing at Georgia Tech.

"It's a geographic form of polarization," said Desmarais, who is also the associate director of the Center for Social Data Analytics. "It's a phenomenon that political scientists refer to as the 'hollowing out of the political center.' Forty years ago, you could find many moderate Democrats and moderate Republicans in Congress. You don't find that now -- and we're also seeing this dynamic in these migration patterns."

Other factors, such as jobs, still play an important role in decisions about where to move, according to the researchers.

"We included both the political factors and the usual economic drivers of migration," said Desmarais. "Those economic factors still explain more of the variance. People are not going to say, 'I'm going to move to a county that is politically similar to me, but where I can't find a job.'"

He added that political scientists are concerned that as people geographically separate themselves, they may be less likely to encounter different points of view, which may then further widen this political divide.

"Now that they're in that partisan environment, it could mean they might not pick up exposure to people from across the aisle and pick up other kinds of opinions," said Desmarais. "They're just going to be exposed to their own echo chamber or their political bubble by being either in a very Democratic county or a very Republican county."

According to the researchers, who report this findings in the current issue of PLOS One, the study appears to back previous research that shows that political preferences may be guiding where people choose to live.

"There is some micro-level research that we cite in our paper that experimentally shows that people really do want to live among co-partisans," said Desmarais. Co-partisans are people who share political preferences.

The researchers used county-to-county data on migration flows from the U.S. Internal Revenue Service, which spanned 14 years, from 2002 to 2015. For county-level presidential election patterns, the researchers used the County Presidential Election Returns, an open dataset that covered 2004, 2008, 2012 and 2016. This range of elections covers the administrations of the two previous presidents, several changes in party leadership over Congress and one redistricting period. The figures are also influenced by the 2016 election of the current president.

The researchers examined counties in the contiguous states with a population of more than 20,000 people, based on figures from the 2010 Census.

The researchers used the computational resources of the Institute for Computational and Data Sciences' advanced computing infrastructure.

"This was a really big project that needed a large amount of computational power," said Desmarais. "We ran all of our analysis on the high-performance computing cluster."
The National Science Foundation and the Institute for CyberScience at Penn State supported this research.

Penn State

Related Politics Articles from Brightsurf:

Fashion's underappreciated role in presidential politics
New research reveals style plays an underappreciated role in presidential politics and has meaningful consequences for presidential power.

'Lazy use' of term populist has helped to legitimize far-right politics
New analysis from academics at the University of Bath into the media's use of the term 'populism' highlights how its overuse has clouded important debates about nationalism, racism, and xenophobia.

Justice for all: How race and American identity may affect politics
New Penn State research examined whether feeling like you belong in America -- or not -- affected how members of different races and ethnicities participated in politics.

Women quotas in politics have unintended consequences
Women continue to be scarce in the halls of power.

The use of jargon kills people's interest in science, politics
When scientists and others use their specialized jargon terms while communicating with the general public, the effects are much worse than just making what they're saying hard to understand.

Stressed out: Americans making themselves sick over politics
Nearly 40% of Americans surveyed for a new study said politics is stressing them out, and 4% -- the equivalent of 10 million US adults -- reported suicidal thoughts related to politics.

Study: Children are interested in politics but need better education from parents and schools
The 2020 election is approaching -- how should we talk with children about this election and about politics more broadly?

Forget 'Obamageddon', 'prepping' is now part of mainstream US politics and culture
Criminologist Dr. Michael Mills challenges the traditional view that US 'preppers' are motivated by extreme right-wing or apocalyptic views.

Study examines how picture books introduce kids to politics
Meagan Patterson of the University of Kansas has authored a study in which she analyzed political messages in some of the most popular picture books of the last several years to see how political topics are introduced to children.

US abortion politics: How did we get here and where are we headed?
After Roe v. Wade, the pro-life movement accelerated rapidly, describes Munson in a new paper, 'Protest and Religion: The US Pro-Life Movement,' published last week in the Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics.

Read More: Politics News and Politics Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.