'English votes for English laws' has not given England a voice in parliament, study finds

November 27, 2016

'English votes for English laws' (EVEL) has not enhanced England's voice in the UK Parliament, according a 12-month study by researchers at Queen Mary University of London (QMUL). The study says that "greater attention should be paid to the challenge of enhancing England's voice in the UK parliament".

Finding the good in EVEL, published by the Centre for Constitutional Change with the support of the Economic and Social Research Council and the Constitution Unit at UCL, is the first in-depth analysis of how EVEL has worked since its introduction in October 2015. The report is written by Professor Michael Kenny and Daniel Gover from QMUL's Mile End Institute.

It recommends that the House of Commons should consider introducing a cross-cutting English Affairs select committee as a forum for debating and scrutinising English issues. The report says that a forum such as this might help show that England's interests are being voiced and heard at Westminster.

Currently, English stages are held at the end of a bill's Commons passage, when most scrutiny and debate has already taken place. The report finds that there has been almost no interest in in these English stages in their current form, with most lasting around two minutes.

The report finds that while the current version of EVEL is flawed, it has avoided most of the problems predicted by its critics. The authors conclude that EVEL "can be justified as a pragmatic response to devolution to other parts of the UK."

Michael Kenny, Professor of Politics and Director of the Mile End Institute at QMUL said: "So far, this system has been operating out of political sight but EVEL may well turn into a headache for Theresa May. Because most English MPs are Tories, the current system makes little difference to legislative outcomes.

Professor Kenny said: "But what would happen if a majority in the Commons were to vote down legislation that followed on from a 'hard Brexit' deal which only applied to England and had the support of a majority of English MPs? And what if measures such as the government's proposals to introduce more grammar schools in England are blocked by a Commons majority that includes the SNP and other non-English members? These rules matter and they could be more flexible, transparent and balanced."

The report makes several recommendations for reform. These fall into four categories: doing more to facilitate expression of England's 'voice' at Westminster (as opposed to simply a veto right); applying more consistently the 'double veto' that is central to the government's reform; reducing the complexity of the system; and taking steps to improve its legitimacy.

Queen Mary University of London

Related Voice Articles from Brightsurf:

Tone of voice matters in neuronal communication
Neuronal communication is so fast, and at such a small scale, that it is exceedingly difficult to explain precisely how it occurs.

Primate voice boxes are evolving at rapid pace
Scientists have discovered that the larynx, or voice box, of primates is significantly larger relative to body size, has greater variation, and is under faster rates of evolution than in other mammals.

Do you want a cheerleader or a critic? The Voice shows how we really choose our mentors.
We think that we will choose our personal and professional advisors based on reasoned criteria about their expertise, competence and experience.

Grainger engineers voice localization techniques for smart speakers
Smart speakers offer a variety of capabilities to help free up both our time and our hands.

Using voice analysis to track the wellness of patients with mental illness
A new study finds that an interactive voice application using artificial intelligence is as accurate at tracking the wellbeing of patients being treated for serious mental illness as their own physicians.

Teenagers less likely to respond to mothers with controlling tone of voice
Teenagers are less likely to cooperate and put effort into their mother's requests when they are said in a controlling tone of voice, researchers have found.

how the brain distinguishes between voice and sound
Is the brain capable of distinguishing a voice from phonemes?

Sound mind: Detecting depression through voice
AI algorithms can now more accurately detect depressed mood using the sound of your voice, according to new research by University of Alberta computing scientists.

The voice is key to making sense of the words in our brain
Scientists at the Basque research centre BCBL conclude that the voice is fundamental for mentally presenting the meaning of words in the brain.

A wearable vibration sensor for accurate voice recognition
Professor Kilwon Cho of Chemical Engineering and Professor Yoonyoung Chung of Electronic and Electric Engineering from POSTECH successfully developed a flexible and wearable vibration responsive sensor.

Read More: Voice News and Voice Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.