Landmark study uncovers reasons behind recurring back injury

December 01, 2001

COLUMBUS, Ohio -- In the first study of its kind, Ohio State University researchers believe they have found an important factor in recurring back injury: our natural tendency to avoid using hurt muscles.

The findings, to appear in the December 1 issue of the journal Spine, point to new forms of physical therapy and new safety standards for physical labor in the workplace. This work could potentially affect the incidence of severe back injury and reduce the millions of dollars in health costs and lost workdays created by these injuries every year.

William Marras, professor of industrial, welding, and systems engineering, and his colleagues discovered that people tend to compensate for back injuries by using many inappropriate muscles in place of the muscles that hurt.

"People with back pain guard the injured area by using more muscles than they need to," Marras said. "The more muscles they use, the greater the load there is on the spine."

For instance, injured people may employ muscles in their abdomen or sides, or other, uninjured back muscles, even though these muscles are not necessary for lifting.

The study revealed that people with back injuries unknowingly inflict twice as much twisting force on their spine, and 1.5 times as much compressive force as uninjured people, when lifting the same object.

Over time, greater loads on the spine lead to more serious back injuries, such as disc degeneration, which require surgery. What's more, lifting objects slowly, as injured people also tend to do, only intensifies the harm. "Moving slowly just increases the length of time the spine has to endure those extra forces," Marras said.

Marras directs Ohio State's Biodynamics Laboratory, where he and his colleagues conducted this study to compare how people with and without back injuries use their muscles.

His colleagues included Sue Ferguson, a research scientist, Benjamin Lucas, a graduate student, and Kermit Davis, a former graduate student who is now an assistant professor of environmental health at the University of Cincinnati.

The Ohio Bureau of Workers Compensation funded this research to combat back injury -- the number one reason Americans miss work, after the common cold. Across the country in 1999, more than 420,000 people missed work because of back injury. Each lost an average of 6 days on the job, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.

The Ohio State study compared the lifting activity of 22 uninjured adults to that of 22 people who were suffering from lower pack pain (LBP). The LBP participants were recruited from the practice of Purnendu Gupta, an orthopaedic surgeon formerly at Ohio State, and now at the University of Chicago.

No other studies have been able to make such a comparison, because injured people are often unwilling or unable to perform the physical exertions necessary for these tests, Marras said.

To solve this problem, the researchers created a mathematical technique to obtain needed information from the partial exertions an injured person can comfortably provide.

The technique takes data from an injured person's electromyogram (EMG), a measure of a muscle's electrical activity, and calibrates it to provide a basis for comparison with an uninjured person's EMG. The researchers were then able to calculate what the forces on the spine would be if an injured person were able to exert the full power of their muscles.

For the same exertion, LBP participants used many more muscles in the back, creating much larger forces on the spine.

Marras likened the forces on the spine to a seesaw: "When people apply all those extra muscles, it's as if they're pushing down on the short end of a seesaw, and trying to lift something on the far end," Marras said. "They exert more force, and to little effect."

On average, the LBP participants weighed more than their uninjured counterparts, and weight also increases force on the spine. That's why losing weight can help people recover from back injury, Marras said.

Another route to recovery, physical therapy, may have to change to prevent recurring back injuries, he added.

Typical therapy for back injury involves helping the patient regain strength. But just as important as strength is learning to use back muscles appropriately.

"After a back injury, people need to re-learn how to use their muscles naturally. The timing of the muscles working together needs to return to normalcy," Marras said.

The study suggests that this new rehabilitation strategy, combined with weight loss and a redesign of the workplace, could reduce the possibility of repeat back injuries.

The U.S. Occupational Health and Safety Administration maintains strict guidelines for preventing healthy people from becoming injured, but not for preventing injured people from becoming injured again.

Marras said the guidelines for injured workers would have to be even more strict. "There are some motions, such as bending to lift far away from the body, or lifting something off the floor, that a normal person can do once in a while without serious harm. Those are the kinds of motions an injured person should never do at all," Marras said. "Bottom line -- you can send people back to work after a back injury, but you have to be very careful about what you have them do."

Recurring back injuries debilitate workers, and create massive health care costs. In Ohio, for example, 16 percent of people with back injuries account for 80 percent of the total health care costs for this injury. That's because the recurring injuries suffered by this 16 percent cost so much more to treat than first-time injuries.

For a first-time back injury, the cost of drugs, doctor's visits, and physical therapy can add up to as much as $10,000. But for more severe cases -- the kind that result when a person is hurt over and over again -- the costs can climb as high as $300,000, Marras said.
-end-
Contact: William Marras, 614-292-6670; Marras.1@osu.edu. Written by Pam Frost Gorder, 614-292-9475; Gorder.1@osu.edu

Ohio State University

Related Physical Therapy Articles from Brightsurf:

NIH gene therapy startup to increase AAV gene therapy efficiency
Maximizing the efficiency of the adeno-associated virus (AAV) platform for gene therapy is the aim of a new pilot project of the National Institutes of Health (NIH).

Factors maximize impact of yoga, physical therapy on back pain in underserved population
New research shows that people with chronic low back pain (cLBP) have better results from yoga and physical therapy compared to reading evidence-based self-help materials.

New Human Gene Therapy editorial: Concern following gene therapy adverse events
Response to the recent report of the deaths of two children receiving high doses of a gene therapy vector (AAV8) in a Phase I trial for X-linked myotubular myopathy (MTM).

New hope for ACL injuries: Adding eccentric exercises could improve physical therapy outcomes
People with anterior cruciate ligament injuries can lose up to 40% of the muscle strength in the affected leg--with muscle atrophy remaining a big problem even after ACL reconstruction and physical therapy.

Dual therapy reduces risk for bleeding better than triple therapy for patients with atrial fibrillation
Use of dual therapy with a direct oral anticoagulant (DOAC) plus P2Y12 inhibitor was associated with reduced risk for major bleeding compared with triple therapy with a vitamin K antagonist (VKA) plus aspirin and P2Y12 inhibitor for patients with nonvalvular atrial fibrillation after percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI).

Light therapy for immune cells helps with side effects of cancer therapy
A frequent side effect of cancer immunotherapies can probably be stopped by light activation of immune cells, as researchers at the Medical Center -- University of Freiburg have shown.

Virtual physical therapy after knee replacement brings similar outcomes, lower costs
A virtual system for in-home physical therapy (PT) provides good outcomes for patients undergoing rehabilitation following total knee arthroplasty (TKA) -- with lower costs than traditional in-person PT, reports a study in the Jan.

Individualized physical therapy reduces incontinence, pain in men after prostate surgery
For decades, therapy to strengthen pelvic muscles has been the standard treatment for men dealing with urinary incontinence after prostate surgery.

Yoga and physical therapy as treatment for chronic lower back pain also improves sleep
Yoga and physical therapy (PT) are effective approaches to treating co-occurring sleep disturbance and back pain while reducing the need for medication, according to a new study from Boston Medical Center.

BU finds physical therapy access may reduce opioid prescriptions
Low back pain is one of the most common conditions Americans seek care for--and one of the more common reasons for an opioid prescription.

Read More: Physical Therapy News and Physical Therapy Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.