Intelligence cooperation faces obstacles

December 02, 2010

"Bureaucrats put spanners in the works; they are unwilling to release information when politicians try to start new cooperation", says political scientist Björn Fägersten from Lund University in Sweden. He will shortly be defending a new thesis on international intelligence cooperation.

Björn Fägersten has studied the reasoning European countries use when considering cooperation with another country's intelligence services. The advantages are that they gain access to one another's information and expertise on specific regions. Countries are particularly keen to cooperate on terrorism and organised crime.

"It could be both disastrous and embarrassing if they withheld information about a planned attack in another country", says Björn Fägersten.

Other types of intelligence cooperation can entail disadvantages, for example in the case of development trends in other countries - countries are less willing to exchange information if they believe the knowledge could lead to economic advantages.

However, even cooperation where all parties have something to gain can meet with opposition, according to Björn Fägersten. In such cases it is often because civil servants within different organisations look after their own interests.

"The various intelligence organisations overlap one another and when the staff have put time and money into an issue, they are unwilling to relinquish their areas of expertise", says Björn Fägersten.

He mentions Europol, which despite repeated demands for cooperation on counter-terrorism has difficulty delivering. One example is the politically initiated Counter Terrorism Task Force that was set up after 11 September. It was a fiasco and in the end was wound up because it did not receive support.

"If the civil servants don't see any value in an initiative, it becomes very difficult to carry it out. Politicians should be more aware of this when they establish new structures", says Björn Fägersten.

Björn Fägersten has studied intelligence cooperation within three different European forums: the European Police Office (Europol), the EU Joint Situation Centre (SitCen), and the security services' forum for counter-terrorism, the Counter-Terrorism Group (CTG). Besides open sources in the form of decisions and parliamentary hearings, the study is based on interviews with individuals from a total of 11 European countries with links to intelligence services.
-end-
Björn Fägersten will defend his thesis on 4 December at 10.15 in Edens hörsal. The thesis is entitled Sharing Secrets - Explaining International Intelligence Cooperation.

Björn Fägersten can be contacted at bjorn@fagersten.se or on +46 708 122438.

Please contact the author to obtain a review copy of the thesis.

Lund University

Related Terrorism Articles from Brightsurf:

Recovery from grief is a slow, difficult process for families of terrorism victims
People who lose loved ones to terrorism are at a particularly high risk of developing Prolonged Grief Disorder, a condition characterized by severe and persistent longing for the deceased and reduced functioning in daily life.

COVID-19 and terrorism: Assessing the short and long-term impacts of terrorism
A new report authored by Pool Re and Cranfield University's Andrew Silke, Professor of Terrorism, Risk and Resilience, reveals how the COVID-19 pandemic is already having a significant impact on terrorism around the world.

Hate speech dominates social media platform when users want answers on terrorism
People often resort to using hate speech when searching about terrorism on a community social media platform, a study has found.

How news coverage of terrorism may shape support for anti-Muslim policies
Terrorist attacks committed by the so-called Islamic State are rising in Western countries.

An understudied form of child abuse and intimate terrorism: Parental Alienation
According to Colorado State University social psychologist Jennifer Harman, about 22 million American parents have been the victims of behaviors that lead to something called parental alienation.

'Terrorism does not terrorize' claims new study
The impact of terrorist events on mental wellbeing may be less significant than we are led to believe, argue the authors of a significant new study published today in The Lancet Psychiatry.

Philosopher warns against 'drifting into state terrorism'
Philosopher Michael Quante calls for social debate on ethically justifiable warfare -

Deeper understanding of ISIS propaganda can help in the fight against terrorism
Douglas Wilbur, a retired major in the U.S. Army and a doctoral student in the School of Journalism at the University of Missouri, is continuing the fight against ISIS by studying the Islamic militant organization's propaganda texts and communication strategies.

Are current efforts to combat terrorism actually increasing the risk of future attacks?
A public health perspective of the rise in terrorism and violent radicalization points to social determinants of health including discrimination, social isolation, and stigmatization of groups such as Muslims or Arab American as factors that can make people more vulnerable to extremist influences.

Weaponizing the internet for terrorism
Writing in the International Journal of Collaborative Intelligence, researchers from Nigeria suggest that botnets and cyber attacks could interfere with infrastructure, healthcare, transportation, and power supply to as devastating an effect as the detonation of explosives of the firing of guns.

Read More: Terrorism News and Terrorism Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.