Study spells out hat trick for making hockey safer

December 03, 2012

TORONTO, Dec. 3, 2012--Mandatory rules such as restricting body checking can limit aggression and reduce injuries in ice hockey, making the game safer for young people, a new study has found.

Rule changes could be incorporated into existing programs that reward sportsmanship and combined with educational and other strategies to reduce hockey injuries, according to researchers at St. Michael's Hospital.

The need to address the issue is critical, said Dr. Michael Cusimano, a neurosurgeon. Brain injuries such as concussions frequently result from legal or illegal aggressive body checking and account for 15 per cent of all injuries to nine-to-16-year-olds. On some teams, up to one-quarter of players will suffer a concussion in a season. These injuries also reflect a pervasive "win at all costs" culture now seen in many sports.

"Given that brain injuries are so common and that they can have permanent effects, we need to introduce measures that we know have been shown to work to reduce the numbers of children and youth suffering these injuries in sport," said Dr. Cusimano, who has researched and written extensively about traumatic brain injuries such as sports concussions.

The researchers conducted a systematic review of 18 studies that evaluated interventions to reduce aggression-related injuries. The results of their review appear online today in the Canadian Medical Association Journal.

Thirteen of those studies evaluated mandatory rules in minor hockey leagues in Canada and the United States to lessen aggression. Of those, 11 found lower penalty or injury rates. Decreases in penalties ranged from 1.2 to 5.9 per game, while injury rates decreased three-fold to 12-fold.

In three studies of educational interventions, there were inconsistent effects on penalties and no significant effects on injuries. In two studies of cognitive behavioural interventions (changing thinking to change behaviour), reductions in aggressive behaviour were found.

Three of the13 studies on rule changes examined the Fair Play Program that makes sportsmanship a component of final league standings. Points are awarded to teams at the end of every season or tournament for staying below a pre-established limit of team penalties per game. Nine studies looked at the enforcement of rules prohibiting body checking and one examined the impact of legal punishment on the frequency of aggressive behaviour in the NHL.

"Rule changes essentially alter the culture of a sport and clearly define acceptable behaviour for players, coaches, parents and officials," said Dr. Cusimano.

He said that while educational programs can also do this to a certain extent, their effectiveness depends on the involvement of all stakeholders and a simultaneous change in their attitudes. For this to happen, educational interventions need to be effective, implanted repeatedly, have an obvious reward and have widespread application.

This has occurred in New Zealand, where the Rugby Union and the country's Accident Compensation Corp. developed a 10-point mandatory injury prevention program in 2001 that has resulted in a 13 per cent decrease in neck, back and spine injuries.

Dr. Cusimano said that introducing Fair Play Program rules with educational interventions and enforced rules hold promise in reducing injuries from aggressive behaviour. He said that Fair Play could have more impact if it incorporated stricter rule enforcement to penalize high-risk behaviour such as a head hit or check from behind. He suggested Fair Play could also remove the maximum number of penalties a team is allowed because critics say it encourages players to believe they are entitled to fill their quota and it potentially limits the number of penalties referees call in a high-stakes game.
About St. Michael's Hospital

St. Michael's Hospital provides compassionate care to all who enter its doors. The hospital also provides outstanding medical education to future health care professionals in more than 23 academic disciplines. Critical care and trauma, heart disease, neurosurgery, diabetes, cancer care, and care of the homeless are among the Hospital's recognized areas of expertise. Through the Keenan Research Centre and the Li Ka Shing International Healthcare Education Center, which make up the Li Ka Shing Knowledge Institute, research and education at St. Michael's Hospital are recognized and make an impact around the world. Founded in 1892, the hospital is fully affiliated with the University of Toronto.

For more information or to interview Dr. Cusimano, please contact:

Leslie Shepherd
Manager, Media Strategy
St. Michael's Hospital
Phone: 416-864-6094 or 647-300-1753
Inspired Care. Inspiring Science.

St. Michael's Hospital

Related Brain Injuries Articles from Brightsurf:

Global MRI data offers hope for improving treatment of brain injuries
A sizable research consortium coordinated by NTNU and St. Olavs Hospital will analyse large amounts of MRI exam data from around the world.

Head and neck injuries make up nearly 28% of all electric scooter accident injuries
A Henry Ford study is sounding the alarm on the rise of electric scooter injuries, and particularly head and neck injuries, since the 2017 introduction of e-scooter rideshare programs in urban centers.

Concussion discovery reveals dire, unknown effect of even mild brain injuries
Even mild concussions cause severe and long-lasting impairments in the brain's ability to clean itself, and this may seed it for Alzheimer's, dementia and other neurodegenerative problems.

AI successfully used to identify different types of brain injuries
Researchers have developed an AI algorithm that can detect and identify different types of brain injuries.

Boys with inattention-hyperactivity face increased risk for traumatic brain injuries
McGill-led research shows that boys exhibiting inattention-hyperactivity at age 10 have a higher risk for traumatic brain injuries (TBIs) in adolescence and adulthood.

Antipsychotics associated with increased risk of head, brain injuries in persons with AD
The use of antipsychotics is associated with increased risks of head and brain injuries among persons with Alzheimer's disease, according to a recent study from the University of Eastern Finland.

Brain model offers new insights into damage caused by stroke and other injuries
A UB researcher has developed a computer model of the human brain that more realistically simulates actual patterns of brain impairment than existing methods.

Antipsychotic medications linked to brain injuries in individuals with Alzheimer's disease
New findings published in the Journal of the American Geriatrics Society reveal that use of antipsychotic medications was associated with an increased risk of head injuries in a study of individuals with Alzheimer's disease.

Soldiers, athletes could improved outcomes from traumatic brain injuries
A traumatic brain injury is often easily suspected and can be confirmed and treated if necessary following an injury using a blood analysis, but scientists are reporting that even one mild blast to the brain can cause very subtle but permanent damage as well.

Peptide hydrogels could help heal traumatic brain injuries
Traumatic brain injury (TBI) -- defined as a bump, blow or jolt to the head that disrupts normal brain function -- sent 2.5 million people in the U.S. to the emergency room in 2014.

Read More: Brain Injuries News and Brain Injuries Current Events is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to