Banning Chemicals To Protect Ozone May Aggravate Global Warming

December 04, 1997

CHAMPAIGN, Ill. -- Some of the chemicals being phased out to protect the ozone layer offer offsetting benefits, such as reducing global warming, a University of Illinois researcher says.

"By independently addressing the issues of ozone depletion and global warming, we are jeopardizing desirable options for one effect based on lesser -- or even inconsequential -- impacts on the other," said Don Wuebbles, director of the Environmental Council at the U. of I. and a professor of atmospheric sciences. "We need to stop looking at these issues as though they are separate from one another, and start considering them together when we determine environmental policy."

In the Nov. 7 issue of the journal Science, Wuebbles and colleague James Calm, an engineering consultant in Great Falls, Va., write that the regulatory actions on certain chemicals -- imposed by both the Montreal Protocol and the U.S. Clean Air Act to protect the ozone layer -- will have little impact on stratospheric ozone while contributing unnecessarily to global warming.

"Most of the chemicals responsible for ozone depletion are also greenhouse gases," Wuebbles said. "Chlorofluorocarbons [CFCs], for example, tend to be severe offenders for both the depletion of ozone and for global warming. The need for their regulation is unambiguous."

But there are other industrially important chemicals that fall into the gray area. "Some hydrochlorofluorocarbons [HCFCs], for example, have very short atmospheric lifetimes and mostly decompose before reaching the upper atmosphere," Wuebbles said. "Effects on ozone depletion from some of these compounds are likely to be negligible. Nevertheless, they are still being tightly regulated and eventually the intention of the rulings is that they be banned entirely."

One such chemical, HCFC-123, is a high-performance refrigerant commonly used in the cooling systems of large buildings. Some of the intended replacements for HCFC-123 not only have much longer atmospheric lifetimes that could contribute to global warming, but they also are far less energy efficient.

"High efficiency translates into reduced emissions of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases from associated energy use, which, in net impact, dwarf those from incidental releases of the refrigerant itself," Wuebbles said. "High efficiency also reduces fuel and other resource requirements.

"It is probable that HCFC-123 and several other CFC replacements would have survived the ban if the global warming regulations had been implemented before the ones for ozone," Wuebbles said. "With keener awareness of the more limited options to reduce global warming, the framers of the Montreal Protocol and the U.S. Clean Air Act might have been more cautious in rejecting chemicals with minimal impacts and offsetting benefits.

"There are many other chemicals that also have special uses, small impacts, and where the replacements for them would cause other problems or issues," Wuebbles said. "In such cases, it might make more sense to reconsider current policy and allow the continued use of some chemicals."
-end-


University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

Related Global Warming Articles from Brightsurf:

The ocean has become more stratified with global warming
A new study found that the global ocean has become more layered and resistant to vertical mixing as warming from the surface creates increasing stratification.

Containing methane and its contribution to global warming
Methane is a gas that deserves more attention in the climate debate as it contributes to almost half of human-made global warming in the short-term.

Global warming and extinction risk
How can fossils predict the consequences of climate change? A German research team from Friedrich-Alexander Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg (FAU), the Museum of Natural History Berlin and the Alfred Wegener Institute compared data from fossil and marine organisms living today to predict which groups of animals are most at risk from climate change.

Intensified global monsoon extreme rainfall signals global warming -- A study
A new study reveals significant associations between global warming and the observed intensification of extreme rainfall over the global monsoon region and its several subregions, including the southern part of South Africa, India, North America and the eastern part of the South America.

Global warming's impact on undernourishment
Global warming may increase undernutrition through the effects of heat exposure on people, according to a new study published this week in PLOS Medicine by Yuming Guo of Monash University, Australia, and colleagues.

Global warming will accelerate water cycle over global land monsoon regions
A new study provides a broader understanding on the redistribution of freshwater resources across the globe induced by future changes in the monsoon system.

Comparison of global climatologies confirms warming of the global ocean
A report describes the main features of the recently published World Ocean Experiment-Argo Global Hydrographic Climatology.

Six feet under, a new approach to global warming
A Washington State University researcher has found that one-fourth of the carbon held by soil is bound to minerals as far as six feet below the surface.

Can we limit global warming to 1.5 °C?
Efforts to combat climate change tend to focus on supply-side changes, such as shifting to renewable or cleaner energy.

Global warming: Worrying lessons from the past
56 million years ago, the Earth experienced an exceptional episode of global warming.

Read More: Global Warming News and Global Warming Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.