Use of recommended strategies to improve resident shift handoffs in internal medicine residency programs

December 06, 2016

Survey responses from internal medicine residency program directors reported large variation in implementation of recommended handoff techniques and educational strategies to teach handoffs in internal medicine training programs, according to a study appearing in the December 6 issue of JAMA, a medical education theme issue.

National organizations have recommended specific strategies to improve resident handoffs, such as dedicated time and space to perform handoffs, standardized templates, and supervision by senior physicians. How these best-practice recommendations are implemented across programs is unknown. Charlie M. Wray, D.O., M.S., of the San Francisco Veterans Affairs Medical Center, and colleagues examined internal medicine residency program directors' responses to the 2014 Association of Program Directors in Internal Medicine electronic survey, in which they were asked to report implementation of handoff strategies within 3 domains: properties of verbal handoffs (i.e., dedicated time), properties of written handoffs (i.e., use of electronic health records [EHRs]), and educational resources (i.e., didactic lectures).

Among all programs, 234 of 361 (65 percent) responded to the survey. Most program directors (61 percent) were very or somewhat satisfied with the handoff strategies used at their institutions. Implementation of handoff strategies ranged from 6 percent to 67 percent, with the most frequent strategies being dedicated time (67 percent), didactic lectures (64 percent), overlapping shifts (61 percent), ward-based teaching by residents (61 percent), and allowing the receiver access to patient records (60 percent).

Statistically significant differences in the proportion of program directors who were satisfied were observed for those implementing vs not implementing 4 strategies: having a dedicated room, supervision by a senior resident, EHR-enabled handoff, and receiver given written copy of sign out. Implementation ranged between 47 percent (EHR-enabled handoff) and 59 percent (receiver given written copy of sign out), with 12 percent implementing all 4 strategies.

"Discordance between low implementation and high program director satisfaction may indicate confusion regarding which practices are best for their setting because of the lack of strong or consistent evidence," the authors write. "Also, program directors may want to implement these handoff strategies but face significant barriers, such as an EHR unable to facilitate shift handoffs or lack of local expertise to lead interactive workshops."

"Future work to disseminate and implement recommended handoff strategies is warranted."
(doi:10.1001/jama.2016.17786; the study is available pre-embargo at the For the Media website)

Editor's Note: All authors have completed and submitted the ICMJE Form for Disclosure of Potential Conflicts of Interest and none were reported.

To place an electronic embedded link to this study in your story This link will be live at the embargo time:

The JAMA Network Journals

Related Educational Strategies Articles from Brightsurf:

Homicides near schools affect students' educational outcomes
Homicides near schools negatively impact on the educational attainment of children, a new study in the Journal of Labor Economics reports.

COVID-19 study confirms low transmission in educational settings
New research from University of Sydney finds COVID-19 transmission rates in NSW schools and early childcare education and care settings were minimal, particularly between children and from children to adults.

Online educational videos boost cancer knowledge
Online health videos can be an important source of cancer education, according to Rutgers researchers.

A study of educational sabotage
A study published in the journal Violence Against Women by a domestic violence expert at The University of Texas at Arlington focuses on an overlooked form of psychological abuse -- educational sabotage.

Monitoring educational equity
A centralized, consistently reported system of indicators of educational equity is needed to bring attention to disparities in the US education system, says a new report by the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine.

Schools that are socially connected have similar educational outcomes
Ivan Smirnov, a researcher from the Higher School of Economics, analysed the data of 36,951 students from 590 schools of Saint Petersburg and found that there is a strong correlation between the educational outcomes of a school and its digital neighbours.

School-based health services and educational attainment
A new article from the Prevention Research Center of the Pacific Institute for Research and Evaluation examines relationships between availability and use of school-based health centers among adolescents and educational attainment in adulthood.

Significant disparities between educational groups in smoking during pregnancy
With the help of a multidisciplinary register and questionnaire study, Finnish researchers showed that both the educational level and its occupational orientation predict the mother's smoking during early pregnancy.

Educational videos in clinics increased adolescent HPV vaccinations
Showing parents and children an educational video while they wait during a routine medical visit could lead to more people choosing HPV vaccination according to Regenstrief Institute, Indiana University School of Medicine, and IU Richard M.

Impact of a psycho-educational team in early breast cancer patients' coping strategies
The main purpose of the psycho-educational groups was to help women with breast cancer, learn how to cope with the physical, emotional, and lifestyle changes associated with cancer as well as with medical treatments that can be painful and traumatic.

Read More: Educational Strategies News and Educational Strategies Current Events is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to