No clear evidence of a decrease in child maltreatment across 6 countries despite decades of policies designed to achieve this

December 08, 2011

A Review of child maltreatment trends and policies across six countries/states (England, USA, Sweden, New Zealand, Western Australia [Australia], and Manitoba [Canada]) shows that there is no clear evidence of a decrease in child maltreatment across these nations, despite decades of polices designed to achieve such a reduction. The Review is written by Professor Ruth Gilbert, UK Medical Research Council (MRC) Centre of Epidemiology for Child Health, UCL Institute of Child Health, London, UK, and colleagues across these six nations.

The authors found that, after the mid-1990s, the rates of violent deaths and maltreatment-related injuries remained stable in most settings. Only in Sweden and Manitoba did decreases in violent deaths coincide with decreases in admissions to hospital related to injury related to maltreatment. Officially-recognised physical abuse or neglect mostly remained stable across the six nations, but other indicators of agency notification, investigation, or placement in out-of-home care increased, particularly in infants.

Lower levels of maltreatment indices in Sweden than in the USA are, say the authors, consistent with lower rates of child poverty, parental risk factors, and policies providing higher levels of universal support for parenting in Sweden. A snapshot of the maltreatment-related data from 2004-6 showed that violent deaths in the USA were more than five times higher in the USA than in Australia or Sweden, which had the lowest rates. However the authors noted little variation between countries in the rate of maltreatment-related injury admissions and officially-recognised physical abuse. Child protection investigations were much more common in the USA (1 in every 20 children) and New Zealand (1 in 25) children than in Western Australia (1 in 170). Placement in out-of-home care was also ten times higher in Manitoba than in Sweden or Manitoba, with 3% of infants placed outside of their homes each year. Rates for infants in England (0.7%), New Zealand (0.6%), and the USA (0.6%), were around twice as high as in Western Australia (0.3%) or Sweden (0.3%). While these analyses represented a small and not statistically significant increase in England, subsequent data from the UK Department of Education show a 9% increase between 2009 and 2010 in rates of placement of infants outside of their homes. The Review found clear evidence of rises in rates of out-of-home placement in Western Australia (2% per year since the mid-1990s for children aged over 1 year), Sweden (rising 3% per year for infants), and the USA (4% per year for children over 1 year).

The authors say: "We argue for improved research to underpin these very expensive policies that profoundly affect the lives of a substantial minority of children in our countries. Most urgent, in view of increases in out-of-home care, is the need for high-quality, randomised controlled trials to assess the effectiveness of this intervention."

Professor Gilbert says*: "We would urge caution in the interpretation of these results, as there could be a number of explanations for this. Small changes may be occurring but could not be detected by the study."

She adds*: "For too long, policy has been driven by high profile deaths of individual children. We need to invest in population-based studies to inform policy. We also need to be able to link health and social care data to understand which professionals are seeing these children in order to improve coordination of services. Such linkage is done in Western Australia and Manitoba, where it is proving to be an important tool for child health policy."
-end-
For Professor Ruth Gilbert, UK Medical Research Council (MRC) Centre of Epidemiology for Child Health, UCL Institute of Child Health, London, UK, please contact Hayley Dodman or Claire Brunert, UCL Institute of Child Health press office T) 44-207-239-3126/3178 E) hayley.dodman@gosh.nhs.uk / claire.brunert@gosh.nhs.uk

Note to editors: *Quote direct from Prof Gilbert not found in text of Review

Lancet

Related Infants Articles from Brightsurf:

Most infants are well even when moms are infected by COVID-19
Infants born to women with COVID-19 showed few adverse outcomes, according to the first report in the country of infant outcomes through eight weeks of age.

Probiotic may help treat colic in infants
Probiotics -- or 'good bacteria' -- have been used to treat infant colic with varying success.

Deaf infants' gaze behavior more advanced than that of hearing infants
Deaf infants who have been exposed to American Sign Language are better at following an adult's gaze than their hearing peers, supporting the idea that social-cognitive development is sensitive to different kinds of life experiences.

Initiating breastfeeding in vulnerable infants
The benefits of breastfeeding for both mother and child are well-recognized, including for late preterm infants (LPI).

Young infants with fever may be more likely to develop infections
Infants with a high fever may be at increased risk for infections, according to research from Penn State College of Medicine.

Early term infants less likely to breastfeed
A new, prospective study provides evidence that 'early term' infants (those born at 37-38 weeks) are less likely than full-term infants to be breastfeed within the first hour and at one month after birth.

Infants are more likely to learn when with a peer
Researchers at the University of Connecticut and University of Washington looked at the mechanisms involved in language learning among nine-month-olds, the youngest population known to be studied in relation to on-screen learning.

Allergic reactions to foods are milder in infants
Majority of infants with food-induced anaphylaxis present with hives and vomiting, suggesting there is less concern for life-threatening response to early food introduction.

Non-dairy drinks can be dangerous for infants
A brief report published in Acta Paediatrica points to the dangers of replacing breast milk or infant formula with a non-dairy drink before one year of age.

Infants can't talk, but they know how to reason
A new study reveals that preverbal infants are able to make rational deductions, showing surprise when an outcome does not occur as expected.

Read More: Infants News and Infants Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.