Study finds simple ways to increase participation in EITC

December 10, 2015

It is estimated that roughly seven million Americans each year -- or 25 percent of those eligible -- fail to claim the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC), the primary channel through which the government supports the working poor. Economists and policymakers have long been puzzled over why millions of low to moderate income individuals voluntarily forego credits worth, on average, a month of income.

To shed new insight into why so many people fail to sign up for valuable government benefits, and to identify strategies to improve participation, Carnegie Mellon University's Saurabh Bhargava led a first-of-its kind field experiment with the Internal Revenue Service. Published in the recent issue of the American Economic Review, the study strategically modified the appearance and content of tax claiming notices and worksheets in such a way that permitted a better understanding of how confusion, informational complexity and program stigma affected the decision not to claim.

The IRS distributed the re-designed mailings to over 35,000 eligible non-claimants in California to determine which mailings led to the highest response. The study found that small changes to the appearance of the tax notices, such as a cleaner layout, a modestly shorter claiming worksheet, or displaying the amount of the potential credit in the headline, led significantly more individuals to claim than mailings with typical government complexity.

"Many government policies are shaped by standard economic theories that assume people are rational and self-informed," said Bhargava, an assistant professor of economics in CMU's Department of Social and Decision Sciences. "This study suggests that complexity and small administrative burdens or 'hassles' can deter regular people from acting in their own interest, even when the stakes are large."

The authors examined the low participation rates for the EITC because the costs of claiming -- merely filling out and returning a form -- appeared to be low, while the benefits -- some were eligible for credits over $5,000 -- can be substantial. The field study, along with additional surveys of thousands of low-income individuals, suggested that the absence of claiming is not the result of stigma or the amount of time required to apply for a credit -- explanations favored by traditional economic theory -- but instead the result of 'psychological frictions,' such as low levels of program awareness, confusion regarding eligibility and inattention to program information.

Intriguingly, across recipients of all of the new mailings, 22 percent claimed a credit, despite these individuals having already received an earlier, but complicated, notice from the IRS. This indicates that a mere reminder can lead a substantial number of individuals to claim benefits.

Overall, the study led to additional claiming of about $4 million in credits among a group owed about $26 million in benefits. The study estimated that redesigning and expanding the distribution of notices could lead to several hundred thousand additional claimants in a population not highly sensitive to traditional incentives.

Since the completion of the study, the IRS has begun to circulate redesigned notification forms. And, because other government assistance programs have even more severe challenges getting eligible individuals, often in dire economic need, to sign up for benefits, Bhargava sees this type of work as having widespread relevance.

"This study demonstrates the value and need for rigorous evidence-based approaches to public policy. It also suggests that, in an increasingly complicated world, simplicity and a commonsense recognition of how individuals make decisions can play a critical role in the ultimate success of policies like the EITC," Bhargava said.

Carnegie Mellon University

Related American Economic Review Articles from Brightsurf:

How religion can hamper economic progress
Study from Bocconi University on impact of antiscientific curricula of Catholic schools on accumulation of human capital in France during the 2nd Industrial Revolution could hold lessons on impact of religion on technological progress today.

More economic worries mean less caution about COVID-19
Workers experiencing job and financial insecurity are less likely to follow the CDC's guidelines for COVID-19, such as physical distancing, limiting trips from home and washing hands, according to a Washington State University study.

Evolutionary theory of economic decisions
When survival over generations is the end game, researchers say it makes sense to undervalue long shots that could be profitable and overestimate the likelihood of rare bad outcomes.

Economic alien plants more likely to go wild
An international team of researchers led by University of Konstanz ecologist Mark van Kleunen has compiled a global overview of the naturalization success of economic plants, showing that economic use in general, as well as the number and nature of economic uses, are crucial to their establishment in the wild.

Better science through peer review
The BioScience Talks podcast features discussions of topical issues related to the biological sciences.

The American Heart Association and the American College of Cardiology publish new joint 2019 Clinical Performance and Quality Measures for Adults with High Blood Pressure
Outlines 22, 2019 new measures for the diagnosis and treatment of high blood pressure (HBP), including 6 performance measures, 6 process quality measures and 10 structural quality measures.

Misperceptions about racial economic progress are pervasive
The vast majority of Americans underestimate the magnitude of economic inequality between Whites and racial minorities, particularly black and Latinx people, new data indicate.

Clarifying the economic value of adjusting the power consumption
The economic value of demand response that adjusts the power consumption has not been clarified.

Colonial policies can result in economic growth
A new study in the Review of Economic Studies suggests that areas where Dutch colonizers built sugar factories in the 19th century are more developed today.

Review on dynamical downscaling methods
Dynamical downscaling is one of the major approaches to obtain finer-scale climate information.

Read More: American Economic Review News and American Economic Review Current Events is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to