Nav: Home

Measuring radiation damage on the fly

December 13, 2016

Cambridge, Mass. -- Materials exposed to a high-radiation environment such as the inside of a nuclear reactor vessel can gradually degrade and weaken. But to determine exactly how much damage these materials suffer generally requires removing a sample and testing it in specialized facilities, a process that can take weeks.

An analytical method developed by researchers in the Department of Chemistry at MIT and applied by members of MIT's Mesoscale Nuclear Materials Laboratory could change that, potentially allowing for continuous monitoring of these materials without the need to remove them from their radiation environment. This could greatly speed up the testing process and reduce the preventive replacement of materials that are in fact safe and usable.

The findings are being reported this week in the journal Physical Review B, in a paper by graduate student Cody Dennett, assistant professor of nuclear science and engineering Michael Short, and six others.

When it comes to measuring radiation damage in materials, Short says, "most of the current ways are slow and expensive." For example, the method considered to be the gold standard for such testing, transmission electron microscopy (TEM), produces comprehensive data on many of the defects in the material that are responsible for changes in its properties. But not all the defects that affect the material's properties can be seen in the TEM, so the test does not provide complete data.

"We're not just interested in how many voids or vacancies you have," Short says, referring to places where one or more atoms are missing from the material's crystal lattice. "What we really want to know is how the material properties are changing."

The team found the answer in a technique called transient grating spectroscopy. Essentially, this is a way of measuring the thermal and elastic properties of materials by inducing and monitoring acoustic waves on the material's surface. Though the system only "sees" the outer surface of the materials, those acoustic vibrations are affected by subsurface defects in the material's structure. The effect is similar to the way geologists can construct a picture of Earth's interior layers by studying the way seismic waves propagate in different directions.

The system creates these acoustic oscillations by using two pulsed laser beams aimed at the sample in such a way that the light waves of the two beams cause an interference pattern. This interference pattern causes heating at the sample surface, generating a standing acoustic wave. The motion of the surface caused by this wave can be monitored by another set of lasers. "We create rippling acoustic waves," Short says, "and measure how fast they move and how quickly they decay," without physically contacting the material in any way.

The team's work initially faced some skepticism. "People said 'how do you know [this technique] is sensitive enough?'" Short says. But with careful experiments that "almost perfectly" matched theoretical simulations, they proved the necessary sensitivity, he says. "Those critical questions were important for us to hear, and motivated us to conduct this study."

For one test, the team compared two batches of aluminum samples that were composed of perfect single crystals with different surface orientations. Though the internal atomic arrangement was different, "they looked identical to the eye or in the microscope," he says. "We put them all in our device, and we were able to sort them all out."

To follow up on their initial work, the researchers are now working to prove their technique's sensitivity to tiny defects in a material's structure. "We're creating simple defects and then measuring the signals, to predict the impact," Short says. "We want to show how sensitive we can get."

The team used different materials in their tests but focused mostly on single-crystal aluminum. They chose that material because it was one of the most challenging, Short explains. "As you rotate the sample, its acoustic response changes" because of the different alignment of the crystal structure to the laser-induced surface acoustic waves. "But it changes very little. So if we can sense those subtle changes in wave speed in aluminum, then we're well-prepared to measure radiation effects" in other materials. The results of those tests showed that their device is sensitive enough to detect changes in acoustic wave speed as small as one-tenth of 1 percent. And it can provide its answers "in seconds, versus months or years" for existing methods.

The method the researchers developed to directly simulate transient grating spectroscopy is as important as the measurements themselves, they say. Using careful molecular dynamics simulations, the researchers were able to accurately predict the expected response of copper and aluminum, and confirm this prediction with measurements. "The most powerful implication for these simulations," Short says, "is that we can create new structures in the computer and predict their signals. Some defects are too complex for us to predict their signals using theory alone. That is where simulation comes in." The ability to use simulation to explain experimental measurements on the atomic scale is also "extremely enlightening," he says.

"Now, we can take a data point about every five minutes, where usually you would get a few data points per month," he says. That speedier testing could be crucial in enabling the development of new generations of cladding material for nuclear fuel for advanced new reactors, he says. "Now, the biggest drawback to deploying new reactors is materials, and the biggest drawback to that is testing. If we can go from months to seconds, we can get around that bottleneck."

Although their initial tests were done with larger laboratory setups, Short says it should be quite straightforward to reproduce those functions in a small, portable device that could be carried around for field tests or permanently mounted in strategic monitoring points within a reactor vessel.
The research team also included Penghui Cao, an MIT postdoc; Sara Ferry, an MIT graduate student; Alejandro Vega-Flick of the CINVESTAV Unidad Merida in Mexico; Alexei Maznev, a research scientist in MIT's Department of Chemistry; Keith Nelson, the Haslam and Dewey Professor of Chemistry at MIT; and Arthur Every at the University of Witwatersrand in South Africa. The work was supported by the National Science Foundation, Transatomic Power, Inc., and the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission.

Additional Background

ARCHIVE: Scrutinizing radiation's impact

ARCHIVE: Michael Short's Institute odyssey: From freshman to professor

Massachusetts Institute of Technology

Related Aluminum Articles:

Scientists created nanopowders for the synthesis of new aluminum alloys
The research team of Siberian Federal University together with the scientists of the Krasnoyarsk Scientific Center of the SB RAS has developed a method for the synthesis of aluminum alloys, the use of which will allow the creation of new types of products with improved characteristics based on aluminum.
Scientists created nanopowders for the synthesis of new aluminum alloys
The research team of Siberian Federal University together with the scientists of the Krasnoyarsk Scientific Center of the SB RAS has developed a method for the synthesis of aluminum alloys, the use of which will allow the creation of new types of products with improved characteristics based on aluminum.
Examining exploding stars through the atomic nucleus
Imagine being able to view microscopic aspects of a classical nova, a massive stellar explosion on the surface of a white dwarf star (about as big as Earth), in a laboratory rather than from afar via a telescope.
Ultrathin protective layer brings quite a bit more stability to perovskite solar cell
The addition of a few nanometers of a thin layer of aluminum oxide protects a perovskite solar cell against humidity -- still a major stumbling block to the commercial application of this new type of solar cell.
See-through circuitry
Indium tin oxide, the current material used in transparent electronics, is becoming very expensive thanks to the rarity of indium.
Pitt receives NSF grant to study how aluminum alloy microstructures form in real time
A grant from the National Science Foundation will enable researchers at the University of Pittsburgh to utilize a one-of-a-kind transmission electron microscope developed at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory to examine in real time how microstructures form in metals and alloys as they solidify after laser beam melting.
Tracking the aluminum used to purify tap water
A Kobe University research group have developed a new analysis method that uses magnetic fields to quickly and accurately measure the concentration of aluminum used to purify tap water.
An attempt to reduce materials cost of autoclaved aerated concrete production
To reduce the materials cost of autoclaved aerated concrete (AAC) production, these two types of solid waste could theoretically be used as the aerating agent and silica source, respectively.
Making some of the world's most durable materials corrosion-resistant
Borides are among the hardest and most heat-resistant substances on the planet, but their Achilles' Heel, like so many materials', is that they oxidize at high temperatures.
Method stabilizes, enhances phosphorene
A Northwestern University research team used organic chemistry to covalently react a single-molecule-thick layer onto phosphorene to stabilize its reactivity to open air.

Related Aluminum Reading:

Streamline Aluminum Trailers: Restoration & Modification (Restoration How-to Sa Design)
by Daniel Hall (Author)

The iconic shape and appearance of a streamline aluminum trailer sitting at a campsite or being pulled down the highway has captivated collectors and vacationing hobbyists for nearly 90 years. During this time, the exterior appearance of the trailer has changed very little, so recollections can range from seeing a 1937 Dodge Pickup to a 1969 Impala hauling one of these beauties. Today, restored rarities from Airstream, Silver Streak, Boles Aero, Clipper, and Spartan can command as much as $100,000 in the marketplace. These trailers have become symbols of American pop culture for several... View Details

Aluminum: Properties and Physical Metallurgy (06236G)
by John E. Hatch (Author), John E. Hatch (Editor)

Comprehensive information for the American aluminium industry Collective effort of 53 recognized experts on aluminium and aluminium alloys Joint venture by world renowned authorities-the Aluminium Association Inc. and American Society for Metals. The completely updated source of information on aluminium industry as a whole rather than its individual contributors. this book is an opportunity to gain from The knowledge of the experts working for prestigious companies such as Alcoa, Reynolds Metals Co., Alcan International Ltd., Kaiser Aluminium & Chemical Corp., Martin Marietta Laboratories and... View Details

Boatbuilding with Aluminum: A Complete Guide for the Amateur and Small Shop
by Stephen F. Pollard (Author)

Make your boat dreams come true with aluminum

Aluminum is the ideal boatbuilding material--light, economical, maintenance-free, and easy to work with. This second edition offers you everything you need to know about working with this material, from welding to fitting out and painting.

View Details

The Adventures of an Aluminum Can: A Story About Recycling (Little Green Books)
by Alison Inches (Author), Mark Chambers (Illustrator)

Peek into this diary of an aluminum can as it goes on a journey from inside a bauxite rock, to the manufacturing line, to the store shelf, to a display on a bookshelf, to a garbage can, and finally to a recycling plant where it emerges into its new life…as a baseball bat!

This 8x8 paperback storybook is told from the point of view of an enthusiastic aluminum can. The diary entries are fun and humorous, yet point out the ecological significance behind each product and the resources used to make it. View Details

Backyard Aluminum Casting
by One Street Components (Author)

Build your own aluminum casting foundry. Cast bicycle shift levers or whatever else you have in mind. Learn to melt and cast scrap aluminum for profit or just for fun. While much of this book discusses the Bike Shift Lever project (read more at under Programs, One Street Components), readers will learn how to cast just about anything using scrap aluminum and make a profit doing so. In addition to casting, the book also offers guidance on product marketing and sales. Starting with foundry and casting basics, readers learn how to build an inexpensive charcoal-fired furnace using a... View Details

Aluminum Dreams: The Making of Light Modernity (MIT Press)
by Mimi Sheller (Author)

How aluminum enabled a high-speed, gravity-defying American modernity even as other parts of the world paid the price in environmental damage and political turmoil.

Aluminum shaped the twentieth century. It enabled high-speed travel and gravity-defying flight. It was the material of a streamlined aesthetic that came to represent modernity. And it became an essential ingredient in industrial and domestic products that ranged from airplanes and cars to designer chairs and artificial Christmas trees. It entered modern homes as packaging, foil, pots and pans and even infiltrated... View Details

Aluminum in America: A History
by Quentin R. Skrabec (Author)

The history of aluminum: metallurgy, engineering, global business and politics--and the advance of civilization itself. The earth's most abundant metal, aluminum remained largely inaccessible until after the Industrial Revolution. A precious commodity in 1850s, it later became a strategic resource: while steel won World War I, aluminum won World War II.
A generation later, it would make space travel possible and the 1972 Pioneer spacecraft would carry a message from mankind to extraterrestrial life, engraved on an aluminum plate. Today aluminum, along with oil, is the natural resource... View Details

The Metallurgy of Anodizing Aluminum: Connecting Science to Practice
by Jude Mary Runge (Author), Joy M. Kaufman (Illustrator)

In this book, the history of the concepts critical to the discovery and development of aluminum, its alloys and the anodizing process are reviewed to provide a foundation for the challenges, achievements, and understanding of the complex relationship between the aluminum alloy and the reactions that occur during anodic oxidation.  Empirical knowledge that has long sustained industrial anodizing is clarified by viewing the process as corrosion science, addressing each element of the anodizing circuit in terms of the Tafel Equation.  This innovative approach enables a new level of... View Details

Aluminum Ore: The Political Economy of the Global Bauxite Industry
by Robin Gendron (Editor), Mats Ingulstad (Editor), Espen Storli (Editor)

As the key component in aluminum production, bauxite has become one of the most important minerals of the last one hundred years. To some it brought economic and political advantage, but for many others, its development left a legacy of exploitation. Aluminum Ore explores the history of bauxite in the twentieth century and the global forces that this history represents, from its strategic development in the First World War to its role in the globalization of markets as companies from the northern hemisphere vied for the resources of the south. Featuring essays by scholars from around... View Details

Flinders Aluminum Fabrication Corporation v. Mismo Fire Insurance Company
by Rebecca Sitterly (Author), Laurence M. Rose (Author), Frank D. Rothschild (Author)

Flinders Aluminum Fabrication Corporation burned to the ground on the night of November 16. George Avery, an employee of the plant, died inside. Plaintiff Arthur Jackson, the sole stock holder of the company, has filed a civil action law suit to recover the $1,667,000 in damages owed from the policy issued by defendant Mismo Fire Insurance Company. The defendant has refused to pay, claiming that the fire was the work of an arsonist, thus indicating deliberate fraud. Mismo asserts that Jackson conspired with others to burn the plant in order to collect what was promised in the insurance... View Details

Best Science Podcasts 2018

We have hand picked the best science podcasts for 2018. Sit back and enjoy new science podcasts updated daily from your favorite science news services and scientists.
Now Playing: TED Radio Hour

The Consequences Of Racism
What does it mean to be judged before you walk through the door? What are the consequences? This week, TED speakers delve into the ways racism impacts our lives, from education, to health, to safety. Guests include poet and writer Clint Smith, writer and activist Miriam Zoila Pérez, educator Dena Simmons, and former prosecutor Adam Foss.
Now Playing: Science for the People

#465 How The Nose Knows
We've all got a nose but how does it work? Why do we like some smells and not others, and why can we all agree that some smells are good and some smells are bad, while others are dependant on personal or cultural preferences? We speak with Asifa Majid, Professor of Language, Communication and Cultural Cognition at Radboud University, about the intersection of culture, language, and smell. And we level up on our olfactory neuroscience with University of Pennsylvania Professor Jay Gottfried.