Constipation is not the scourge we think it is

December 21, 2000

Civilization and the colon: constipation as the "disease of diseases"

Western civilisation has been misled about the dangers of constipation, says medical historian James Whorton from the University of Washington. And doubts have now been raised about the effectiveness of bran cereals to ward off bowel cancer.

In this week's Christmas issue of the BMJ, Professor Whorton reports that for well over two centuries Britons and North Americans have been convinced that constipation is the fundamental "disease of civilization." The "compelling suspicion" that a stagnant bowel filled with putrefying matter can become an infective source for the rest of the body is not supported by the science, he says. There is no evidence that bowel toxins can leach into the circulation.

The Ancient Egyptians first suggested the notion that the body can poison itself as a result of constipation, known as intestinal autointoxication. And every subsequent civilization has enthusiastically embraced the idea, writes Professor Whorton. But constipation has done more to provide clinicians with the obvious solution to undiagnosable ailments and the manufacturers of cereals, laxatives, purgatives, and devices with a rich source of revenue, he says.

Even though intestinal autointoxication is no longer considered medically valid, writes Professor Whorton, Western civilization's preoccupation with its bowels and their movement, or lack of, continues unabated. But, he says, given recent trial evidence showing that high fiber cereals, and bran in particular, do not protect against bowel cancer, it is perhaps time to challenge this "cherished tenet of popular health. culture."
-end-
Contact:

Professor James Whorton, Department of Medical History and Ethics, University of Washington School of Medicine, Seattle, USA
Email: jwhorton@u.washington.edu

BMJ

Related Bowel Cancer Articles from Brightsurf:

Immunotherapy for bowel cancer could change clinical practice
A large international trial involving UCL and University College London Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust (UCLH) has found that pembrolizumab, a form of immunotherapy, more than doubled the 'progression free survival' time of patients with a specific subtype of advanced bowel cancer, when compared with chemotherapy.

Shorter radiotherapy treatment for bowel cancer patients during COVID-19
An international panel of cancer experts has recommended a one-week course of radiotherapy and delaying surgery as the best way to treat patients with bowel cancer during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Dramatic increase in bowel cancer in young adults in England
There has been a dramatic increase in the incidence of bowel cancer in adults under the age of 50, according to new research from the University of Bristol, UWE Bristol and University Hospitals Bristol NHS Foundation Trust (UH Bristol).

Genetic 'fingerprints' implicate gut bacterium in bowel cancer
A common type of bacteria found in our guts could contribute to bowel cancer, according to research funded by a £20 million Cancer Research UK Grand Challenge award and published in Nature today (Thursday).

Bowel cancer rates after colonoscopy vary by provider
A colonoscopy is the main test used to detect bowel cancer, but like most tests, it is not always 100% accurate and cancers can be missed.

Researchers identify certain gut bacteria that may be involved in causing bowel cancer
People who have a certain type of bacteria in their guts may be at greater risk of developing bowel cancer, according to research presented at the NCRI Cancer Conference.

Experts advise against routine bowel cancer testing for all over-50s
Routine testing for bowel cancer should not be recommended for everyone aged 50-79 years because, for those at very low risk, the benefit is small and uncertain and there are potential harms, say a panel of international experts in The BMJ today.

Here's proof that bowel cancer screening reduces deaths
New research led by the University of South Australia shows just how effective bowel cancer screening is in helping to reduce the number of bowel cancer deaths by up to 45%.

Antibiotic use linked to heightened bowel cancer risk
Antibiotic use (pills/capsules) is linked to a heightened risk of bowel (colon) cancer, but a lower risk of rectal cancer, and depends, to some extent, on the type and class of drug prescribed, suggests research published online in the journal Gut.

Bowel cancer rising among young adults in Europe
The rate of bowel cancer -- otherwise known as colorectal cancer or CRC -- is rising among adults aged 20-49 in Europe, suggests research published online in the journal Gut today.

Read More: Bowel Cancer News and Bowel Cancer Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.