New direction for NATO must make alliance relevant in current security environment

December 22, 2009

NATO is rethinking its future direction for the first time since the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks, a process that could redirect the Cold War alliance toward contemporary security issues like cyberthreats and piracy, and strengthen its commitment to fragile states like Afghanistan, according to a new RAND Corporation study.

The study examines five directions the alliance might take as it revises its strategic concept to make the organization relevant in today's security environment. The directions are a refocus on Europe, a new focus on the greater Middle East, a focus on fragile states, a focus on nonstate threats and a global alliance of liberal democracies. The study also examines the possibility of combining two or more of the options.

"NATO will need to stay strong in Europe, but it will have to do more than that," said Christopher Chivvis, the study's author and an international security policy analyst at RAND, a nonprofit research organization. "The alliance is in a fight for its existence and will have to combine various roles to stay relevant to both Europe and the United States, but it must also be cautious not to overextend itself."

From its inception in 1949, NATO has offered its members a measure of protection against their common security problems. While those security concerns have changed drastically and become much more complex over time, Chivvis says NATO's members continue to face common threats. These include hybrid threats such as terrorism, cyberthreats, piracy and environmental disasters.

The alliance could be focused regionally, since most threats to allied security originate in the Middle East, or functionally toward operations such as its current effort in Afghanistan, since failed states are "the wellspring of several of the forces that threaten allied security today," Chivvis said.

NATO's members face a host of common security challenges from the Middle East, making the region a logical focal point for the alliance. However, Chivvis says NATO could be an effective tool against nonstate threats if it were willing to commit the resources. Or the alliance could transform itself into an effective tool for the military aspects of coping with state failure. This is an important point when one considers the long-term repercussions if its efforts in Afghanistan should fail.

The report says that NATO's revised strategic concept, a draft of which is expected in spring 2010, offers a chance to rebuild the alliance and create a viable security option for its members for at least the next 10 years to 15 years.

"The differences in strategic vision among its members will make building a common vision for the alliance extremely challenging and some combination of missions will be necessary," Chivvis said. "The optimal strategic concept will allow the organization to be flexible, yet encourage concrete commitments that will diminish further strategic drift."
-end-
The study, "Recasting NATO's Strategic Concept: Possible Directions for the United States," can be found at www.rand.org

The study was prepared by RAND Project AIR FORCE, a federally funded research and development center for studies and analysis aimed at providing independent policy alternatives for the U.S. Air Force.

The RAND Corporation is a nonprofit research organization providing objective analysis and effective solutions that address the challenges facing the public and private sectors around the world. To sign up for RAND e-mail alerts: http://www.rand.org/publications/email.html

RAND is a registered trademark

RAND Corporation

Related Terrorist Attacks Articles from Brightsurf:

Brain imaging study reveals new clues about PTSD in victims of terrorist attacks
A new study published in Science suggests new therapeutic avenues for PTSD patients, after researchers explored the brainq of victims of the November 13, 2015 terrorist attacks in Paris.

Populist Eurosceptics don't gain from terrorist attacks
Populist Eurosceptics don't gain from terrorist attacks Research led by the University of Kent has found that terrorist attacks in Europe don't increase support for populist parties.

Minimizing fuel explosions and fires from accidents and terrorist acts with polymers
When an act of terrorism or a vehicle or industrial accident ignites fuel, the resulting fire or explosion can be devastating.

Terror attacks by Muslims get 357 percent more media coverage than other terror attacks, study shows
Terror attacks carried out by Muslims receive on average 357 percent more media coverage than those committed by other groups, according to research conducted at Georgia State University.

UT Dallas study provides fuller picture of the human cost from terrorist attacks
New research from The University of Texas at Dallas provides a more complete picture of the suffering caused by terrorist attacks.

Perceived race of victims, location determine concern in terrorist attack
In response to an international terrorist attack, the public's level of concern has to do with the locations of the attacks and the perceived identities of the victims, according to a new study by two University of Kansas researchers.

Moderate decline in violent attacks against Jews, but attacks are becoming more brutal
Anti-Semitic violence around the world dropped 9 percent from 2016 to 2017, but a 'dramatic increase' of all other forms of anti-Semitic manifestations has raised 'grave concerns among European Jews regarding their security and the continuation of communal life,' according to an annual report from Tel Aviv University's Kantor Center for the Study of Contemporary European Jewry, published on April 11.

Ideology is not main factor that pushes children to join terrorist groups
Counter-terror efforts based on the assumption that children recruited into extremist groups are motivated by ideology are unlikely to be effective, and could even backfire, concludes a two-year research project led by the United Nations University.

Do terrorist attacks affect ethnic discrimination in the labor market?
Terrorist attacks are known to influence public opinion, but do they also change behaviour?

Are we missing the warning signs to prevent lone terrorist attacks?
The terrorist who killed 12 people and injured dozens more in the 2016 Berlin Christmas Market attack was removed from the country's surveillance list a month earlier, but he presented five specific warning behaviors prior to the attack according to later analysis.

Read More: Terrorist Attacks News and Terrorist Attacks Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.