Dating historic activity at Oso site shows recurring major landslides

December 23, 2015

The large, fast-moving mudslide that buried much of Oso, Washington in March 2014 was the deadliest landslide in U.S. history. Since then, it's been revealed that this area has experienced major slides before, but it's not known how long ago they occurred.

University of Washington geologists analyzed woody debris buried in earlier slides and used radiocarbon dating to map the history of activity at the site. The findings, published online in the journal Geology, show that a massive nearby slide happened around 500 years ago, and not thousands of years ago as some had believed.

"The soil in this area is all glacial material, so one hypothesis is the material could have fallen apart in a series of large landslides soon after the ice retreated, thousands of years ago," said corresponding author Sean LaHusen, a UW doctoral student in Earth and space sciences. "We found that that's not the case -- in fact, landslides have been continuing in recent history."

The study establishes a new method to date all the previous landslides at a particular location. The method shows that the slopes in the area around Oso have collapsed on average once every 500 years, and at a higher rate of about once every 140 years over the past 2,000 years.

"This was well known as an area of hillslope instability, but the question was: 'Were the larger slides thousands of years old or hundreds of years old?' Now we can say that many of them are hundreds of years old," said co-author Alison Duvall, a UW assistant professor of Earth and space sciences.

LaHusen had not yet begun his graduate studies when he asked about studying the history of geologic activity at the Oso site. In late summer of 2014, the researchers began their work wading along riverbanks to look for preserved branches or trees that could be used to date previous landslides.

"When you have a large, catastrophic landslide, it can often uproot living trees which kills them and also encapsulates them in the landslide mass," Duvall said. "If you can find them in the landslide mass, you can assume that they were killed by the landslide, and thus you can date when the landslide occurred."

The team managed to unearth samples of wood buried in the Rowan landslide, just downstream of the Oso site, and the Headache Creek landslide, just upriver of the 2014 slide. Results from several debris samples show that the Rowan landslide, approximately five times the size of the Oso slide, took place just 300 to 694 years ago. The Headache Creek landslide is within a couple hundred years of 6,000 years old.

Previous UW research had shown a history of geologic activity at the Oso site, including previous major landslides and a recent small slide at the same slope that collapsed in 2014. But while the position of past slides and degree of surface erosion can show the order that the older slides happened, it has not been possible to give a date for the past events.

The new study uses the radiocarbon dates for two slides to establish a roughness curve to date other events along a 3.7-mile (6-kilometer) stretch of the north fork of the Stillaguamish River. A roughness curve uses the amount of surface erosion to establish each slide's age. The two dates put firm limits on the curve, so that other nearby slides can be dated from their roughness characteristics without having to find material buried inside each mass of soil.

"This is the first time this calibrated surface dating method has been used for landslide chronologies, and it seems to work really well," LaHusen said. "It can provide some information about how often these events recur, which is the first step toward a regional risk analysis."

Applying the new method for other locations would require gathering samples for each area, they cautioned, because each site has its own soil composition and erosion characteristics.

It's not known whether the findings for the Oso site's history would apply to other parts of the Stillaguamish River, Duvall said, or to other places in Washington state. The researchers are still studying debris from other locations. But the results do have implications for the immediate area.

"It suggests that the Oso landslide was not so much of an anomaly," Duvall said.

She and LaHusen are also working with the UW's M-9 Project, which is studying hazards from magnitude-9 earthquakes along the Cascadia subduction zone. They would like to learn whether landslides across Washington state coincided with past earthquakes, and use simulations of future shaking to predict which places in the state are most vulnerable to earthquake-triggered landslides.
-end-
Other co-authors on the new paper are David Montgomery at the UW and Adam Booth at Portland State University. The study was funded by the National Science Foundation, the Geological Society of America, and the UW's Quaternary Research Center.

For more information, contact Duvall at 650-815-5560 or aduvall@uw.edu and LaHusen at seanlah7@uw.edu.

University of Washington

Related Landslides Articles from Brightsurf:

Simple actions can help people survive landslides
Simple actions can dramatically improve a person's chances of surviving a landslide, according to records from 38 landslides in the US and around the world.

Landslides have long-term effects on tundra vegetation
Landslides have long-term effects on tundra vegetation, a new study shows.

Most landslides in western Oregon triggered by heavy rainfall, not big earthquakes
Deep-seated landslides in the central Oregon Coast Range are triggered mostly by rainfall, not by large offshore earthquakes.

FSU researcher detects unknown submarine landslides in Gulf of Mexico
A Florida State University researcher has used new detection methods to identify 85 previously unknown submarine landslides that occurred in the Gulf of Mexico between 2008 and 2015, leading to questions about the stability of oil rigs and other structures, such as pipelines built in the region.

Climate change could trigger more landslides in High Mountain Asia
More frequent and intense rainfall events due to climate change could cause more landslides in the High Mountain Asia region of China, Tibet and Nepal, according to the first quantitative study of the link between precipitation and landslides in the region.

Martian landslides not conclusive evidence of ice
Giant ridges on the surface of landslides on Mars could have formed without ice, challenging their use by some as unequivocal evidence of past ice on the red planet, finds a new UCL-led study using state-of-the-art satellite data.

Ground failure study shows deep landslides not reactivated by 2018 Anchorage Quake
Major landslides triggered by the 1964 magnitude 9.2 Great Alaska earthquake responded to, but were not reactivated by, the magnitude 7.1 Anchorage earthquake that took place 30 November 2018, researchers concluded in a new study published in Seismological Research Letters.

Rice irrigation worsened landslides in deadliest earthquake of 2018 finds NTU study
Irrigation significantly exacerbated the earthquake-triggered landslides in Palu, on the Indonesian island of Sulawesi, in 2018, according to an international study led by Nanyang Technological University, Singapore (NTU Singapore) scientists.

Precursors of a catastrophic collapse
The flanks of many island volcanoes slide very slowly towards the sea.

Quick reconnaissance after 2018 Anchorage quake reveals signs of ground failure
A day after the Nov. 30, 2018, magnitude 7 earthquake in Anchorage, Alaska, US Geological Survey scientists Robert Witter and Adrian Bender had taken to the skies.

Read More: Landslides News and Landslides Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.