Acute-on-chronic liver failure (ACLF) lacks a universally accepted definition, and recent efforts have proposed consensus organ failure criteria. In this study, we aimed to compare the clinical validity of a recently proposed consensus ACLF framework with the outcome-calibrated A-TANGO classification.
We performed a multinational cohort study including 2,398 patients from the TIH cohort (India) and 2,568 from the CATCH-LIFE cohort (China) who were hospitalized with acute decompensation of cirrhosis. ACLF was defined using A-TANGO and an operationalized version of the 2025 consensus framework. Outcomes were 28- and 90-day mortality. Analyses assessed case capture, overlap, mortality risk, sensitivity, specificity, and net reclassification improvement (NRI).
ACLF prevalence differed substantially by definition. In TIH, A-TANGO classified 79.2% as ACLF versus 42.3% by the consensus definition; in CATCH-LIFE, the corresponding values were 31.4% versus 5.8%, respectively. Most consensus ACLF cases were captured by A-TANGO, which additionally classified 26%–37% of patients as having ACLF. These patients had substantial mortality (28-day: 18.1%–26.9%; 90-day: 33.2%–37.9%), significantly higher than those negative by both frameworks and comparable to established ACLF risk thresholds. A-TANGO showed higher sensitivity for 28-day mortality (TIH: 94.1% vs. 67.8%; CATCH-LIFE: 76.1% vs. 25.6%), whereas consensus criteria were more specific. Reclassification analyses showed improved discrimination with A-TANGO (NRI: 17.1% in TIH; 27.4% in CATCH-LIFE). Within the consensus non-ACLF group, A-TANGO further stratified patients into distinct risk groups with stepwise increase in mortality.
The consensus ACLF framework and A-TANGO classification identify fundamentally different patient populations. The consensus definition captures a smaller, liver-centered phenotype, whereas A-TANGO identifies a broader population that includes a substantial intermediate-risk group with clinically meaningful mortality. These findings demonstrate that harmonization, as currently operationalized, may come at the cost of reduced clinical accuracy, sensitivity, and underdiagnosis of important high-risk phenotypes, with significant potential clinical and regulatory consequences. Rather than replacing outcome-based definitions, future efforts toward harmonization should build upon them. A unified framework must preserve the link between organ failure and mortality that underpins the clinical utility of ACLF, ensuring that convergence enhances rather than diminishes the ability to identify patients at risk of mortality.
Full text
https://www.xiahepublishing.com/2310-8819/JCTH-2026-00267
The study was recently published in the Journal of Clinical and Translational Hepatology .
The Journal of Clinical and Translational Hepatology (JCTH) is owned by the Second Affiliated Hospital of Chongqing Medical University and published by XIA & HE Publishing Inc. JCTH publishes high quality, peer reviewed studies in the translational and clinical human health sciences of liver diseases. JCTH has established high standards for publication of original research, which are characterized by a study’s novelty, quality, and ethical conduct in the scientific process as well as in the communication of the research findings. Each issue includes articles by leading authorities on topics in hepatology that are germane to the most current challenges in the field. Special features include reports on the latest advances in drug development and technology that are relevant to liver diseases. Regular features of JCTH also include editorials, correspondences and invited commentaries on rapidly progressing areas in hepatology. All articles published by JCTH, both solicited and unsolicited, must pass our rigorous peer review process.
Follow us on X: @xiahepublishing
Follow us on LinkedIn: Xia & He Publishing Inc.
Journal of Clinical and Translational Hepatology
Consensus versus Outcome-based Definitions of Acute-on-chronic Liver Failure: Implications for Risk Stratification and Case Identification
15-May-2026