New research in Economic Inquiry demonstrates evidence of in-group bias operating within the judiciary—a setting where impartiality is expected.
Using Florida medical malpractice cases with randomly assigned judges, investigators found that sharing a law school with the presiding judge boosted a plaintiff's attorney's probability of recovering damages by approximately 2 percentage points.
The researchers found no comparable effects when judges and lawyers attended different law schools of similar rank or shared the same gender or minority status, suggesting that the result is not driven by school quality or these other observable similarities. The effect was also strongest when the judge was at least 10 years older than the lawyer, consistent with an age-dependent effect.
“Courts are designed to deliver impartial justice, yet our findings show that something as simple as a shared law school can affect whether plaintiffs recover damages,” said corresponding author David Zhang, PhD, of Rice University. He noted that this raises important questions about when ties between judges and lawyers should be disclosed or lead to recusal.
“The fact that observable similarities alone do not explain these patterns highlight the nuances of decision-making in high-stakes cases—and the power of rigorous data collection and research design to uncover what really matters,” added co-author Tianwang Liu, PhD, an independent researcher.
URL upon publication: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/ecin.70080
Additional Information
NOTE: The information contained in this release is protected by copyright. Please include journal attribution in all coverage. For more information or to obtain a PDF of any study, please contact: Sara Henning-Stout, newsroom@wiley.com .
About the Journal
Published since 1962, Economic Inquiry is a highly regarded scholarly journal in economics publishing articles of general interest across the profession. Quality research that is accessible to a broad range of economists is the primary focus of the journal. Join our long list of prestigious authors, including more than 20 Nobel laureates.
About Wiley
Wiley is a global leader in authoritative content and research intelligence for the advancement of scientific discovery, innovation, and learning. With more than 200 years at the center of the scholarly ecosystem, Wiley combines trusted publishing heritage with AI-powered platforms to transform how knowledge is discovered, accessed, and applied. From individual researchers and students to Fortune 500 R&D teams, Wiley enables the transformation of scientific breakthroughs into real-world impact. From knowledge to impact—Wiley is redefining what's possible in science and learning. Visit us at Wiley.com and Investors.Wiley.com . Follow us on Facebook , X , LinkedIn and Instagram .
Economic Inquiry
Alumni Relationships and Judicial Bias
19-Aug-2026