A commentary by Pauls and Downie argues, however, that physicians will simply be seen as an extension of the police and that the negative effect on the patient-physician trust will result in vulnerable patients not disclosing underlying health issues for fear of being reported.
Writing on behalf of the OMA's Section on Emergency Medicine, Ovens points out that patient confidentiality is not an absolute right in Canada and exceptions exist to protect the public good. Regardless, argues Ovens, any victim's personal health information would remain confidential.
p. 1255 Shooting ourselves in the foot: why mandatory reporting of gunshots wounds is a bad idea
-- M.A. Pauls, J. Downie
p. 1256 Why mandatory reporting of gunshots wounds is necessary: a response from the OMA's Executive of the Section of Emergency Medicine
-- H. Ovens
p. 1258 Mandatory reporting of gunshot wounds: rebuttal
-- M.A. Pauls, J. Downie
Canadian Medical Association Journal