Key takeaways:
TAMPA, Fla. (Aug. 26, 2025) – Wind alone does not account for all hurricane-related fatalities. Storm surge and rainfall do as well. Yet the current warning system – the Saffir-Simpson Hurricane Wind Scale – measures a storm’s strength solely by wind speed.
A new research paper published in Nature Scientific Reports and co-authored by Jennifer Collins, a hurricane researcher and University of South Florida geosciences professor, argues that in order to keep people safe, it’s time for a change. The authors propose replacing the SSHWS with the Tropical Cyclone Severity Scale, which incorporates storm surge and rainfall in addition to wind.
“Frequently, people use the storm’s category to decide whether to evacuate,” Collins said. “That’s incredibly dangerous because if they hear it’s only a tropical storm or Category 1, too often no alarm bells go off, and they see no cause for concern.”
The paper cites hurricanes Katrina and Florence as examples. In 2005, Katrina was listed as a Category 3 based on wind speed, but most of the 1,800 deaths and $125 billion in damage were caused by storm surge and rainfall. Similarly, in 2018, Florence made landfall as a Category 1, yet its massive flooding killed 55 people.
It also cites a 2014 study by Edward Rappaport, then-deputy director of the National Hurricane Center, that stated wind is responsible for 8% of hurricane-related fatalities, while storm surge accounts for 49% and rainfall 27%.
“There have been too many instances of incredible loss of life and destruction because a low category number on the SSHWS, or even if it’s listed as a tropical storm, did not match the danger of the storm,” Collins said. “Based on our research, we now know that people are more likely to evacuate if they understand the dangers from rainfall and storm surge in addition to wind.”
Here’s how the TCSS works:
To test public response to these warnings, Collins and her research team conducted an online experiment with 4,000 residents along the Gulf and East coasts – regions frequently threatened by hurricanes.
Participants received forecasts for 10 fictional hurricanes affecting their communities; half received warnings using the SSHWS, and half using the TCSS.
“We were interested in whether better identification of the main hazard would improve precautionary measures,” the paper explains, “and whether the overall category difference would increase evacuation intent for more dangerous storms.”
Questions the participants were asked included:
Those who received the TCSS were more likely to correctly identify the main hazard and significantly more likely to evacuate for non-wind hazards.
“The higher category is important,” Collins said. “According to my evacuation research, many people base their decision to evacuate on that number, not just on the details of the hazard.”
The National Hurricane Center began using the Saffir-Simpson Hurricane Scale in 1971, utilizing pressure, storm surge and wind measurements. But in 2012, that was modified to include only the wind component and was named the Saffir-Simpson Hurricane Wind Scale.
“Without satisfactory and complete information, individuals are likely to miscalculate their personal risk or even be moved to inaction,” the paper reads.
Collins, a native of England who moved from Pennsylvania to Florida in 2005, longed to study evacuation behavior during hurricanes.
After an approximately 10-year lull in hurricanes impacting Florida, she was able to conduct her studies due to Hurricane Matthew in 2016, and then subsequent hurricanes including Irma in 2017 and Ian in 2022. In 2024, hurricanes Helene and Milton provided ample opportunity for her team to study hurricane evacuation behavior in Florida.
At a 2017 hurricane conference, she met University of Amsterdam co-author Nadia Bloemendaal, who shared similar interests. Together with the other co-authors, Jantse Mol from the University of Amsterdam and Hans de and Dianna Amasino of Tilburg University, they developed the TCSS, publishing their findings in 2021 and moving on to testing its effectiveness.
Next, Collins and her co-authors plan to present their research to the National Hurricane Center. While others have suggested changes to the hurricane scale, Collins believes their work offers strong evidence supporting such a shift.
“Change is hard for any institution that’s been doing the same thing for years,” Collins said. “But I’m fairly optimistic that now is the time. We now know many people make decisions based on the category messaging, so we need to ensure that we are communicating with a scale which is more realistic of the severity of the hurricane, considering other hazards which commonly occur, particularly from storm surge and rainfall flooding, which is considered in our scale.”
###
About the University of South Florida
The University of South Florida is a top-ranked research university serving approximately 50,000 students from across the globe at campuses in Tampa, St. Petersburg, Sarasota-Manatee and USF Health. USF is recognized by U.S. News & World Report as a top 50 public university and the best value in Florida. U.S. News also ranks the USF Health Morsani College of Medicine as the No. 1 medical school in Florida and in the highest tier nationwide. USF is a member of the Association of American Universities (AAU), a group that includes only the top 3% of universities in the U.S. With an all-time high of $738 million in research funding in 2024 and as a top 20 public university for producing U.S. patents, USF uses innovation to transform lives and shape a better future. The university generates an annual economic impact of more than $6 billion. USF’s Division I athletics teams compete in the American Conference. Learn more at www.usf.edu .
Scientific Reports
Data/statistical analysis
People
An experimental test of risk perceptions under a new hurricane classification system
19-Aug-2025